Improving current social services is better than UBI – more realistic and more effective
Marco Annunziata, Senior Contributor to Forbes, ’18, July 27, “Universal Basic Income: A Universally Bad Idea,” FORBES, https://www.forbes.com/sites/marcoannunziata/2018/07/27/universal-basic-income-a-universally-bad-idea/?sh=41e7673a3269
Rich societies have a moral obligation to fight poverty and homelessness. To help when you fall on hard times because of health problems or because you lost your job. They have an obligation—and an interest—to broaden access to opportunity, so that your chances of success depend more on how talented and hard-working you are, less on your family circumstances (recognizing that we can never completely level the playing field).
This means a strong and targeted social safety net. The building blocks are familiar: unemployment benefits, health care for the poor, scholarships for bright low-income students.
Social safety nets need to be improved, and it is devilishly hard to strike the right balance between assistance and incentives, to combine strong incentives to work with the assurance that if you lose your job you will still be ok.
Devilishly hard, but that is the problem we need to solve—not how to divide up money that we don’t have. UBI is like granting open-ended unemployment benefits with no requirement to look for work, or financing an indefinite ‘gap year’ to anyone who wants it. It would be nice. We just don’t have the money.