UBI does not provide dignity
Ravi Venkatesan, Chief Executive Officer at Cantaloupe, ’20, April 24, “Universal Basic Income is a threat to Human Dignity,” accessed July 3, 2023, https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/universal-basic-income-threat-human-dignity-ravi-venkatesan/
The COVID-19 crisis has brought the question of Universal Basic Income (UBI) into conversations again. Fortunately, neither President Trump nor Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden are in favor of this.
I am pained by the accelerating inequality in the world and our country. However, UBI will make this worse not better, and here is why.
The fundamental premise of UBI is to create a security blanket for the most vulnerable and poor sections of society, by providing minimum needed income and health care. Noble idea, but the flaw is in reduced motivation to work, for a large portion of the population. There are already forces in play like Artificial Intelligence, which according to the McKinsey Global Institute threatens 25% of American jobs in the next decade alone. Add UBI on top of this, and you take away a large part of the motivation for displaced workers to learn new skills, adapt to the new norm, and find meaningful different jobs.
I recently saw a Science Fiction series called Expanse on Amazon Prime. It shows a society where a majority of the population is on “basic support”. They get basic housing, basic food, healthcare etc., but have no access to higher education, no prospect of social mobility, no ability to improve their lot by working hard. A small portion of the population that is not on basic support, controls everything. They have all the luxuries you can imagine, and the ability to work hard and improve their lot. The people on basic support resent the people that are not on it, for everything they have. The people not on basic support resent the people on it, for being free loaders and living off the taxes that they pay. Crime is a huge challenge, and society is excessively policed.
While this is fiction, it can very quickly and easily become reality. At a fundamental level, humans don’t just want to have their needs met. They aspire to be better, to grow, to learn, to improve, and to contribute. Taking this away would be taking human dignity away. So instead of creating a security blanket through UBI, we should create one through Universal Basic Employment. Target zero unemployment. If the Government can print seemingly limitless amounts of money, in a crisis like the current one, why not increase investments in infrastructure and other areas. Do it in a manner that ensures employment for everyone fit to work.