Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Basic income can’t solve poverty

Scott Sumner ’19, August 31, “A UBI will not eliminate poverty,” ECONLOG POST, https://www.econlib.org/a-ubi-will-not-eliminate-poverty/

I agree with much of that, but not the part about eliminating poverty. If I thought a UBI would eliminate poverty, then I’d support the program. Instead, I favor low wage subsidies.

There are at least three ways of thinking about poverty, and in each case a UBI program would fall short.

1. Perceptions of consumption: Poor people might be defined as those who seem to have very low levels of consumption. Even with a UBI, there would be plenty of people who make poor (or unusual) choices and thus end up with a consumption bundle that looks inadequate. Some would end up homeless, for instance.

2. Relative poverty: Some argue that the poverty line is a moving target, and as we become richer we redefine poverty to include real incomes that were formerly viewed as adequate. A UBI will not eliminate relative poverty because the concept will simply be redefined in the public’s mind to reflect UBI incomes. Think about how the term “minimum wage job” implies a lousy job, regardless of where the minimum wage is set.

3. Absolute poverty: A UBI will require European-style tax rates, as Karelis correctly points out. I’d expect these to eventually lead to European levels of GDP/person. (Not right away.) Thus America’s GDP/person will fall by roughly 25%. When that occurs, the UBI payments will have to be scaled back to levels that are lower than anticipated, and absolute poverty will reappear.

This doesn’t mean the UBI is a bad idea, but we should not expect it to eliminate poverty.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.