Passing UBI would be a huge battle
Bourne, CATO Chairman for the Public Understandings of Economics, ‘18 [Ryan, 08-03-2018, CATO, “A Basic Income Would Crash on the Rocks of Politics”] https://www.cato.org/commentary/basic-income-would-crash-rocks-politics 06-29-2023, RM
We are told poverty would be eliminated, job‐killing automation protected against, innovation would flourish, and working improve dramatically. Opponents aren’t much less hyperbolic. A UBI would supposedly blow up the public finances, drive mass worklessness, and undermine families. But this polarized debate hides the messy truth: the UBI as an idea exposes the current welfare state’s flaws. And any simple UBI would be crushed on the rocks of politics and its inherent trade‐offs. Provided that it was not set at an extremely high level, this need not result in huge swathes of people not working. No doubt some people would pocket the income and not engage in the formal labor market, especially if they currently feel compelled to work to get by. On the margin, more students may prefer to focus on their studies. More parents might decide to spend time with children. Those between jobs may take longer to find positions that genuinely match their skills and talents. A UBI would remove these disincentives for progression or investment in your own human capital. As such, it could increase employment levels for many.