UBI support decreases when applied to immigrants – backlash and racist implementations -- empirics
Bay and Pederson 2006 [Ann-Helén and Axel W, December 2006, Acta Sociologica, “The Limits of Social Solidarity: Basic Income, Immigration and the Legitimacy of the Universal Welfare State https://www.jstor.org/stable/20459958, July 3 2023, ah]
The application of our persuasion experiment suggests, however, that part of this coalition is rather frail. By simply pointing out that an unconditional basic income will include non
citizens living in Norway, many initial supporters are persuaded to change their mind. In addition, a group of initial opponents of basic income are willing to consider such a scheme
if it can be withheld from non-citizens. In other words, the high degree of social solidarity that could motivate support for a basic income scheme does not necessarily encompass newly arrived immigrants and/or ethnic minority groups. Our study cannot give an answer as to
why support for a basic income crumbles when respondents are presented with arguments of including immigrants. The literature on popular support for the welfare state suggests that at least two alternative mechanisms could be at work: (1) People distrust foreigners and suspect that they misuse generous welfare benefits. (2) Solidarity is undermined simply because the 'haves' will not share their resources with the 'have-nots' among the immigrants. It is up to future research to try and disentangle the relative importance of these alternative explanations.
In any case, the analysis of the positions taken by the respondents after the persuasion experiment shows that the mobilization of immigration issues opens up a new front in the
ideological battle over basic income. Proponents of a universal basic income scheme face a 432
two-front war, with one front against an individualistic, anti-egalitarian camp (the traditional right) and another against a more collectivistic, anti-immigration camp (a new populist right).
We suspect that this is also a relevant scenario for political conflicts over the future of the Scandinavian welfare states. One possible strategy by which to adjust the Scandinavian welfare state to the harsh realities of mass immigration and ethnic heterogeneity would be to
try to reduce the demand on social solidarity by abandoning redistributive universalism in favour of a stronger emphasis on income replacement and insurance principles. Another -
very different strategy - would be to severely restrict immigration and move towards a two tier welfare state where the most accessible and generous benefits are withheld from newly arrived immigrants. While Swedish welfare policies can be seen to conform to the first strategy, the second is currently being actively pursued in Denmark (Brochmann and Hagelund, 2005). Of course, these need not be the only available alternatives. The point we want to make is
merely that the conditions for mobilizing popular support for universalistic welfare policies have become more difficult than they were with relatively stable and homogeneous popu
lations during the 'golden era' of welfare state expansion.