False universalism like the plan treats populations as homogenous- can’t account for social difference
Carrey, PhD in public health, and Crammond, RMIT health researcher, 17
[Gemma and Brad, March 2017, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, “A glossary of policy frameworks: the many forms of 'universalism' and policy 'targeting'”, https://www.jstor.org/stable/44363653, Accessed July 12 2023, ah]
However, welfare scholars argue that many states which have been described as 'universal' exclude certain groups by virtue of viewing populations as homogenous.20 This means that they are either not really universal at all, or in practice have been found to incorporate various degrees of targeting.10 The universalist approaches of postwar Britain and the Nordic states have come under attack from scholars concerned with social diversity.10 20-22 Labelled as 'false universalism', they are seen as insufficient for dealing with social difference.20 For example, universalism in the postwar era overlooked the needs of women and minority groups and catered predominately to white men.20 Meanwhile, significant gaps have been found in the 'universalist' programmes of the Nordic states, particularly in benefits for immigrants and guest workers.21 Here, proponents of universalism are accused of confusing 'impartiality' with uniformity and 'equality of treatment' with 'sameness of treatment' regardless of the different needs or ability to access services.8 These ideas have their roots in the work of Ronald Dworkin23, who argued that equal treatment of all individuals is insufficient. Giving equal treatment to all people would mean, for example, providing the same resources to someone with a disability and someone without a disability. To be sensitive to differences in need, Dworkin's theory of equality argued that individuals must be treated differently. Hence, while universalism is regarded as a precondition of equality, it does little to promote redistribution and ignores existing inequalities.23
Others argue that universalism does not truly exist in practice, as judgements are constantly made in the delivery of services about who gets what, against a range of criteria.21 24 For example, within a universal healthcare system, decisions are routinely made about which individuals need which services. Some policy researchers suggest that this can still be considered 'universalism', and merely reflects the need for 'fine tuning' at the margins.10 25