State based universalism sidelines more radical reparations demands. The alternative is to demand global distributive justice via reparations for slavery and colonialism.
Klein, ANU Canberra Public Policy Lecturer & Fouksman, King’s College Social Justice Lecturer, 22 [Edward & Elizaveta, 11/21/2021, Development and Change, Volume 53, Issue 1, January “Reparations as a Rightful Share: From Universalism to Redress in Distributive Justice] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/dech.12695 Accessed 7/2/2023, PE]
REPARATIONS FOR COLONIALISM AND THE WORLD CONFERENCE AGAINST RACISM
In considering a rightful global (re)distribution of wealth, it is hard not to reflect on the foundational violence, oppression and disruption that has played a large role in creating contemporary structures of global political, economic and military order. European colonization of the Americas, Asia, Oceania and Africa continues to be a key aspect of global inequality today. Reparations could right some of the wrongs of not only slavery and the slave trade but also colonization by European empires. In Inglorious Empire: What the British Did to India, Shashi Tharoor (2017) draws on Minhaz Merchant's computation which demonstrates that, in return for profits made over 200 years of imperial rule, Britain could owe India up to US$ 3 trillion (as of 2015). Yet Tharoor argues for atonement over the actual payment of funds. He calls for a ‘symbolic reparation of one pound a year, payable for 200 years to atone for 200 years of imperial rule’ (Tharoor, 2017: 79). Tharoor's preference for atonement over financial settlement or fiscal compensation underscores the importance of the British recognizing the role of colonialism in their own and India's history — a recognition that is largely lacking. This preference can be critiqued for emphasizing recognition at the expense of redistribution (Fraser, 2005). However, Tharoor's point does draw attention to one of the major challenges for universalist notions of a rightful share such as a UBI: as discussed above, it does not necessarily provide recognition of historically specific forms of dispossession, such as colonization and related violence. Recognition can thus be conceptualized as an important part of distributive justice, because it not only acknowledges historical wrongs as a key consideration in making justice-based claims, but also provides pathways to address structural inequalities that were set up under colonial rule and continue today.
Recognition alongside monetary forms of redistributive justice is central to calls for reparations for European colonization. In contrast to Tharoor, others have called for actual compensation to be paid in full, such as in 2009, when the then-president of the African Union, Muammar al-Gaddafi, argued that African states should be given reparations amounting to US$ 77.7 trillion for European colonial plundering (Campbell, 2017). Muammar al-Gaddafi's request followed a long line of leaders from newly independent nations requesting reparative justice from the old European empires. The Organization of African Unity (OAU) sponsored the first pan-African conference on reparations for enslavement and colonization in 1993. This conference was headed by Nigerian Moshood Kashimawo Olawale Abiola and published the Abuja Proclamation (N'Cobra, 1993) which called for:
the international community to recognize that there is a unique and unprecedented moral debt owed to the African peoples which has yet to be paid — the debt of compensation to the Africans as the most humiliated and exploited people of the last four centuries of modern history. … [It] further urges the OAU to call for full monetary payment of repayments through capital transfer and debt cancellation. … Convinced that the claim for reparations is well grounded in International Law, it urges on the OAU to establish a legal Committee on the issue of Reparations. … [It] serves notice on all states in Europe and the Americas which had participated in the enslavement and colonization of the African peoples, and which may still be engaged in racism and neo-colonialism, to desist from any further damage and start building bridges of conciliation, co-operation, and … reparation.
The reference to neo-colonialism in the Abuja Proclamation is particularly important, as it speaks to the structural adjustment policies of the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund that were well underway in countries across Africa at the time the Proclamation was written. Structural adjustment included a range of policies majority world governments had to implement in order to receive aid to service international debt. These policies differed from country to country but focused largely on fiscal deficit, monetary policy, privatization of state assets and trade liberalization. Their effect was to destabilize many local industries, as well as to limit social investment, all furthering economic insecurity and inequality (Herbst, 1990; Moseley et al., 2010). The reference to neo-colonialism in the Abuja Proclamation reflects how structural adjustment deepened African countries’ economic dependence on former colonial powers and current hegemons. As such, the Proclamation was not only tied to past injustices, but was also a response to the continuation of past injustices into the present.
Perhaps the biggest global effort to demand reparations for colonialism came from the 2001 World Conference Against Racism held in Durban. The conference aimed to cover a diverse array of themes including reparations for slavery and colonization, but also to draft an action plan against racial discrimination including preventative measures such as education and international cooperation around the eradication of intolerance and racism. Couched within these diverse demands, reparations were part of a push towards unravelling structures of racism through both recognition and compensation.
Before most of the world's governments and their representatives met to negotiate the final declaration, over 4,000 NGOs met to collectively draft demands focusing on reparations for the trans-Atlantic slave trade, slavery and colonization — all referred to in the NGOs’ draft document as crimes against humanity. Some governments rejected the NGOs’ draft because they felt the wording was too strong and because the draft also singled out Israel for ‘practices of racial discrimination against the Palestinians’ (Lyons, 2002: 1238). The next draft was prepared by governments, who changed the original demands for reparations significantly from reparations as payments to individuals, to payments made in the form of development funds. Specifically, these governments proposed:
reparations in the form of enhanced policies, programs and measures at the national and international level … through the creation of a development fund, the improvement of access to international markets of products from developing countries affected by these practices, the cancellations or substantial reduction of their foreign debt and a program to return art objects and historical documents to countries of origins. (Tan, 2007: 280)
The move from individual payments to development support was controversial. It watered down the NGOs’ position on reparations on three fronts. First, the move to development support was a break in the radical potential of payments made to smaller units, such as individuals or local communities, as individuals have no control over development funds, which are administered by the nation state or multilateral organizations. Also, such aid would remain controlled by and within structures set up by the former colonizers. There is now ample research that shows that loans, aid and development assistance have actually benefited donors more than recipient countries (let alone individuals), for instance via structural adjustment policies as well as poverty reduction strategies and trading agreements (Global Financial Integrity et al., 2015; Herbst, 1990; Klein and Morreo, 2019). Second, paying for development does not necessarily provide recognition of the crimes of former colonizers. Instead, former colonizers can provide development support under the banner of humanitarianism and never admit their role in historical and racial violence. Third, the move towards development support for only post-independence states was a major break with pan-Africanism that interlinked reparations for slavery and for colonization. By only focusing on the development of poor nations, development aid severed collective claims for redress made by both the diaspora of slavery and post-independence nations.
Hilary Beckles describes the shift to development support as momentous, one where ‘African leaders joined with the West to tear down the agenda of reparatory justice for Africans. In so doing, they allowed those who had committed this crime against humanity to walk free’ (Beckles, 2018: 188). The final declaration from the conference removed reference to reparations for colonization altogether, and instead encouraged nations benefiting from the slave trade to provide aid (Lyons, 2002). This emphasis on aid in lieu of reparations has continued: in 2021 Germany acknowledged the Herero-Nama genocide, but as part of this acknowledgement offered additional funding to aid programmes and pointedly ignored calls for reparations.
The strong opposition to calls for reparations from former colonizers and their Western allies is notable. These countries continued to push for development support commitments in order to avoid reparations. At the final preparatory session to the World Conference Against Racism in Geneva, the US sent diplomats to remove references to reparations and Israel (Lyons, 2002), and used the pledge of more aid to African countries as part of their negotiation to achieve this. This lobbying continued at the conference itself, where Western nations again attempted to persuade other governments to not have commitments to reparations feature in the final statement. These tensions continued after the conference. In 2005, Alpha Oumar Konare of Mali, who was then President of the African Union, renewed debates on slavery and colonization in African parliaments and called for reparations. The UK Prime Minister at the time, Tony Blair, was concerned about the implications that such a request would have on the UK, and lobbied the G8 Summit in Gleneagles, Scotland, to instead increase debt relief and aid as part of the ‘Make Poverty History’ campaign. Despite efforts from majority world activists and political leaders, calls for reparations were largely replaced by pledges from the West for more development support and aid (Campbell, 2017).
Western governments, academics and others use a variety of reasons to justify their opposition to reparations. Some argue that colonization was not a crime, and had positive effects for those colonized, such as establishing liberal institutions and national infrastructure. This ignores the extensive historical and contemporary work on the social, economic, ecological and political devastation wrought by colonialism, which continues in development policies that further racialize and dispossess populations (Pailey, 2020; Wilson, 2012).12 Another argument against reparations makes the case that people alive today should not be held accountable for the crimes of their ancestors. Yet if people do not want to be held to account for their ancestors’ crimes, then they must not benefit from the spoils of these crimes — spoils which continue to underpin global privilege (Pogge, 2008). Others make the case that reparations are not pragmatic, and the logistics are simply too difficult — such as the difficulty of identifying those who genuinely deserve to receive compensation for colonial exactions. Yet while enacting reparations is not always straightforward, reparations are already being made (Darity et al., 2010). Guidelines about who is eligible can be worked out through the judiciary, deliberation and survivor-led policy (Barkan, 2007).
Others claim that development aid given since independence has paid off anything owed.13 However, as noted above, development aid has notoriously benefited donors, is given at low amounts, and has continued neo-colonial dominance, all while being framed in charitable rather than in reparative terms by the West. As such, development aid makes claims to improving the human condition and doing good, but simultaneously can obscure the unequal relations underpinning systems of accumulation, dispossession and dominance. Of course, some forms of collective assistance may help repair the ways colonization disrupted and damaged collective processes and structures of colonized societies — for example, support for educational systems, governance arrangements and financial support for cultural revival (Bhargava, 2007; Tan, 2007). Still, the contemporary development apparatus is largely unable to support pluriversal ways of being, and thus carries risks of continued coloniality (Escobar, 2018).