Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

STATUS QUO reparation movements are stuck in liberal schemes like redemption. But the alt doesn’t assume reparations is something to be materially achieved but uses reparations as a weapon to precipitate a crisis in American institutionalist can transforms the social order.

Hartman and Wilderson 3 (THE POSITION OF THE UNTHOUGHT. Author(s): Saidiya V. Hartman, Prof of Comp Lit @ Columbia, Frank B. Wilderson, Prof at UC Irvine, Source: Qui Parle, Vol. 13, No. 2 (Spring/Summer 2003), pp. 183-201. Published by: University of Nebraska Press)

S. VH. - And I think the underlying question is, "Where do we go from here?" F. W - Is that leading us to reparations? S.VH. - Yes. I've been thinking about the notion of focusing one's appeal to the very state that has inflicted the injury. The reparations movement puts itself in this contradictory or impossible position, because reparations are not going to solve the systemic ongoing production of racial inequality, in material or any other terms. And like inequality, racial domination and racial abjection are produced across generations. In that sense, reparations seem like a very limited reform: a liberal scheme based upon certain notions of commensurability that reinscribe the power of the law and of the state to make right a certain situation, when, clearly, it cannot. I think too that such thinking reveals an idealist trap; it's as if once Americans know how the wealth of the country was acquired, they'll decide that black people are owed something. My God! Why would you assume that? Like housing segregation is an accident! I think that logic of "if they only knew otherwise" is about the disavowal of political will. Why is the welfare state dismantled, even though it's actually going to affect more white women and children than black people? Because it has to do with that political will and an antipathy to blackness that structures .. . FW. - That structures institutions. And your work on empathy shows that; it helps us to understand how important blackness is to the libidinal economy of white institutionality. Now, I think I'm fair in generally characterizing the reparations debate and those who've renewed it - Randall Robinson and company - by saying that they got a tiger by the tail, and then didn't want the tiger to do its thing.29 The reparations people present the issue to blacks as though slavery is an essentially historical phenomenon that ended, but the effects of which put blacks at what they call, you know, "an unfair disadvantage" to those in other positions who are also chasing the American dream. Through such a move the reparations folks literally waste a political weapon, they dull the knife, they keep the tiger in the cage, because here is a weapon which could spew forth in untold directions: I'm thinking here of Nat Turner's greatest night. Instead, that weapon is a denuded or, maybe a policed method of conveyance. They're trying to simultaneously mobilize and manage black rage. If reparations were thought of not as something to be achieved, but as a weapon that could precipitate a crisis in American institutionality, then it could be worked out a lot differently from the way it's presented. One could present a reparations agenda in the way in which you present your book, dealing with the despotism of black positionality as it moves from generation to generation, from historical moment to historical moment - with despotism being the almost ahistorical constant. Unleash the tiger and let it do its thing. S. VH. -- At the very least that would entail a transformation of the social order.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.