Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Targeted Universalism is an effective strategy to resist racial capitalism’s race AND class based dispossession.

Klein, ANU Canberra Public Policy Lecturer & Fouksman, King’s College Social Justice Lecturer, 22 [Edward & Elizaveta, 11/21/2021, Development and Change, Volume 53, Issue 1, January “Reparations as a Rightful Share: From Universalism to Redress in Distributive Justice] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/dech.12695 Accessed 7/2/2023, PE]

However, the issue of targeting on the basis of race in order to repair the damage done by slavery and post-slavery racial discrimination still remains. Warren's proposed solution is to establish what he terms U+BI (universal plus basic income). This is a form of targeted universalism, where a basic income is both universal, and there is an additional top up which is targeted towards racial minorities, and explicitly framed as reparations for slavery and racism. Warren's proposal for a U+BI as reparations, and his explicit tying together of UBI and reparations, raises a number of questions. Why adopt an explicitly universal policy such as UBI as part of the case for reparations, which are meant to explicitly target communities damaged by specific historical occurrences? Warren never directly addresses this question, but perhaps the inclusion (with modifications) of UBI within the Movement for Black Lives agenda points to unstated support for other advantages of a universal rightful share, in particular the justice-based arguments for universal ownership of collective wealth (see for instance Birnbaum, 2016; Sloman, 2018; Van Parijs, 1992). The proposal of U+BI also raises the question of whether this would be a true UBI, and if the ‘plus’ would undermine some of the advantages of universalism. In particular, if historically benefits targeted at disadvantaged groups have frequently been inferior to universal benefits and enjoyed lower levels of support, a U+BI might have the same disadvantage, which a UBI would avoid. Ultimately, this case asks: can a distributory policy framed as a rightful share be both reparative and universal at the same time?

A conceptual framework that provides some fruitful avenues into reconciling these tensions is the writing around racial capitalism. The study of racial capitalism underscores the ways in which race and capitalism have been historically — and continue to be currently — co-created and intertwined (Robinson, 1983), with slavery and ongoing racial dispossession as a key example.10 In the words of Jodi Melamed, capitalist ‘accumulation requires loss, disposability, and the unequal differentiation of human value, and racism enshrines the inequalities that capitalism requires’ (Melamed, 2015: 77). As such, scholars of racial capitalism point out that a focus on class, race or colonialism alone is insufficient to understand both the way capitalism has been constituted and the way it continues to operate today. Instead, race and racialization emerged both out of slavery and colonialism and also out of dispossession and proletarianization, and in turn racialized conceptions of social hierarchies enabled class-based exploitation and dispossession. This was not simply imposed by the ‘West onto the Rest’ (Hall, 1992: 275) in a ‘singular axis of power of colonized/colonizer’ (Virdee, 2019: 6), but also occurred within the West itself. An example of this is the way the Catholic Irish were racialized in industrial England in order to subdivide the working class and channel workers’ disaffection into racialized hierarchies (Robinson, 1983). Thus, alongside the racialization of non-European and colonized populations, which was used to justify both colonial conquests and slavery, came the racialization of parts of Europe, which was used to justify further exploitation.

For instance, Virdee (2019) demonstrates the way race was created by British economic elites in the Virginia colony in the 1600s (where unfree labour initially existed for people of both European and African origins) and was used as a foundational step to build a full slavery economy. In parallel, Virdee uses the example of anti-Irish sentiment in Britain to show the way in which ‘during the middle decades of the 19th century, these theories [of race] were increasingly pressed into service by the ideological apparatuses of the state to defuse the working class insurgency at home [in Britain]’ (2019: 18). By making Catholic Irish the ‘other’ with the categorization of ‘so-called inferior race of Celts’ (ibid.) based on biological features such as nose, chin, forehead and mouth shape, which in turn were linked with supposed inherent personality features such as violence and childishness, the working class in England was further subdivided. Anglo-Saxon men ended up with greater political and economic privileges while subscribing to exclusionary racialized nationalism, which allowed the Irish to be hyper-exploited on the basis of their seemingly inherent otherness.

This was to repeat itself with Eastern European Jewish communities in the early 20th century. Similar racialization of Irish, Southern and Eastern European, Jewish and Hispanic populations occurred in the US. Building on this, Nancy Fraser (2018) makes the case that besides exploitation of wage labourers, capitalism has also been entwined with racial oppression via violent expropriation (both of resources, such as land, and capacities, via slavery or other forms of unfree labour). Fraser argues that the relative political protections of the exploited depend on such hidden, race-based (and politically sanctioned) expropriation. Indeed, Fraser makes the case that expropriation in all forms is built on politically sanctioned distinctions that go beyond the construction of racial difference and include other categories of difference such as gender.

The history of racism is thus entangled with not only slavery but also nationalism, sexism, class mobilization and co-optation (Bhattacharyya, 2018). Theorists of racial capitalism make this point as a critique of a narrow focus on class within the study of capitalism. However, it can also help us understand the ways in which class itself is constituted out of race, and the ways in which race was used as the foundation of economic dispossession that aided class differentiation — both via slavery and other forms of expropriation, and with the formation of super-exploited11 and expropriated racially differentiated groups. Thus, if the super-exploited or expropriated classes within capitalism were themselves largely formed out of invented racial categorization and justified by racism, perhaps class-based reparations can also serve as reparations for racism and dispossession on the basis of race. Perhaps a redistributory UBI (that is, one that is funded through a taxation scheme which leads to the wealthy being net contributors, and the poor net beneficiaries) can be framed as rightfully redressing or repairing both the ravages and dispossession of capitalist accumulation, and also racial dispossession, both in societies that experienced slavery and those that did not but that still exploited certain groups on the basis of racial difference. By going to all and yet redistributing money away from capitalism's winners and to capitalism's victims, perhaps a universal redistributory policy such as UBI could be a reparative rightful share that redresses capitalism's class and race-based dispossession.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.