There are massive logistical hurdles for global reparations, and it risks reinforcing Western-centric forms of global governance.
Klein, ANU Canberra Public Policy Lecturer & Fouksman, King’s College Social Justice Lecturer, 22 [Edward & Elizaveta, 11/21/2021, Development and Change, Volume 53, Issue 1, January “Reparations as a Rightful Share: From Universalism to Redress in Distributive Justice] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/dech.12695 Accessed 7/2/2023, PE]
All these points of resistance to reparations underscore a deep discomfort about the underlying challenges to the West's own myths about modernization and Western progress, which have justified inequality, power and domination (Biondi, 2003). However, problems remain around the concrete ways reparations would function in post-independence contexts. For example, if not development assistance and aid, then what mechanisms could be used to facilitate material redress to people? Would this material redress be made available to individuals via something like a global UBI, or as payments to nation states? If payments were made directly to individuals via a global UBI, would this be focused exclusively around former empire economies paying dividends to individuals in the majority world? Would more recently wealthy countries, such as South Korea, also contribute to this reparative global UBI? And how would such a mechanism connect with people that are stateless, or diaspora dispersed because of colonialism and slavery? Finally, how can the ‘transfer effect’ outlined by Darity et al. (2010) be avoided: that is, how can the majority world avoid reinvesting reparations payments back into structures that benefit its former colonizers?
Some scholars have proposed the idea of a redistributive fund administered by a global organization such as the United Nations, to act in part as a form of reparative justice (Blackburn, 2011; Pogge, 2008). Yet cosmopolitan mechanisms such as the UN system have themselves been critiqued for their risk of becoming supra-global mechanisms that reproduce coloniality via Western-centric and top-down designs of development, democracy and economic growth (inclusive or otherwise). Walter Mignolo (2000: 742) argues that the problem for cosmopolitanism models is how to ‘focus on the coloniality of power and the colonial difference produced, reproduced, and maintained by global designs’. But these challenges are not insurmountable, and considerations as to what decolonial options are available for administering direct reparations beyond the nation state boundaries could be pursed further. Claims for reparations for colonialism continue to be important. They offer pathways not only towards redress for the past, but also for radically altering global distribution in the present. In the words of Tan (2007: 284):
justice here and now, rather than justice then, demands the rectification of these disadvantages. It is not the fact that individuals have been wronged in the past that is calling for greater global redistribution, but the fact that they are being wronged now. They are being wronged now because of the imposition of unjust global arrangements on them, that is, arrangements that fail to treat them with equal respect and concern, independently of whether or not they were also wronged in the past.
It is hard to see how justice-based arguments for a rightful share of historically generated collective wealth can proceed without significant recognition of historical injustices such as colonialism. The arguments raised by proponents of redress for colonization show that recognition together with monetary forms of redistributive justice is needed to address the ordering of global economic, military and political systems that have long promoted Western power and prosperity over the majority of the world.