UBI and FJG are examples of universalism that lessen racial inequality by benefiting all, and avoid paternalism and exclusions associated with past policies.
Klein, ANU Canberra Public Policy Lecturer & Fouksman, King’s College Social Justice Lecturer, 22 [Edward & Elizaveta, 11/21/2021, Development and Change, Volume 53, Issue 1, January “Reparations as a Rightful Share: From Universalism to Redress in Distributive Justice] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/dech.12695 Accessed 7/2/2023, PE]
REDISTRIBUTORY UNIVERSALISM AND REPARATIONS FOR SLAVERY IN THE UNITED STATES
Calls for reparations for slavery and racially based dispossession and discrimination have a long history in the United States, dating back to the early years of European colonization and the triangular trade (Brooks, 2004), and encompass a broad variety of proposals, justifications and forms.5 Many of the arguments for race-based reparations in the US focus not only on the two and a half centuries of slavery in the US, but also on the economic ramifications of racial discrimination in the centuries after the formal end of slavery, which range from Jim Crow segregation laws to discriminatory housing policy, as well as the current racialized mass incarceration system (see for instance Darity, 2008). Advocates of targeted reparations based on race in the US point out that the roots of the US's current wealth lie not only in White democracy and institutions making up what Mills (1997) calls ‘the racial contract’, but also in ‘black plunder’ (Coates, 2014).6
Although reparations have been supported by a number of groups and in a variety of forms in the US, this case study will focus on the reparations agenda of the Movement for Black Lives. This is because some of the Movement's racial justice-based proposals specifically included a universal basic income as part of demands made by the Movement in 2015–17 (MacFarland, 2016; Warren, 2016), making it a particularly useful lens through which to think about the intersections and tensions between claims for universal and reparatory distributional justice. Dorian T. Warren, one of the authors of the demands, placed UBI not under the economic justice heading, but rather under the heading of reparations. Warren points out that a UBI would benefit the poor the most, and that it would thus be particularly helpful to the formerly incarcerated and to cashless poor Black people. The implication here is that Warren sees class and race as inseparable, precisely because the US is a society whose economic system is based on a history of slavery and economic exploitation, discrimination and incarceration on the basis of race.
The argument in favour of UBI as a form of reparations on the basis of the intersection of class and race in a post-slavery society is built on the acknowledgement that class exploitation and expropriation and race are closely tied. Because White Americans earn more on average (due precisely to this history of slavery and post-slavery discrimination), a universal basic income would be taxed back from the wealthy (and largely White) community. Its beneficiaries would be the poor, but due to this history of disadvantage, it would especially benefit Black communities in the US, which have disproportionately high rates of poverty and economic disadvantage.7 Beyond the intersection of class and race, Warren also points out that the universalism and unconditionality of UBI have essential advantages. Not only would universalism prevent a repetition of previous racially discriminatory social policies (such as the New Deal's purposeful exclusion of largely Black agricultural workers), but it would avoid the ‘paternalistic restrictions that rest on racist tropes’ (Warren, 2017b; see also Warren, 2017a) within current social policies, such as food stamps. Also crucial is the fact the UBI does not have a work requirement, particularly in light of the structural racism that continues to exclude Black communities from employment in the US. Indeed, other theorists of race-based reparations in the US have also made a similar case for universal social or distributory programmes that would lessen racial inequality by aiding all; for instance, Darity and Hamilton (2012) propose a federal work guarantee and child development accounts.