Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Federal job guarantee fights structural economic exclusion and reduces racial wealth disparities.

Hamilton, Milano School of International Affairs Econ and Urban Policy Professor, 15 [Darrick, “The Federal Job Guarantee: A Step Toward Racial Justice,” Dissent, 11-9, Accessed 7/16/23, https://www.dissentmagazine.org/online_articles/federal-job-guarantee-racial-justice-darrick-hamilton/ ] -grh

Yet over the past forty years, regardless of education, the black unemployment rate has remained roughly twice that of whites. In fact, there has been only one year in the last forty years, 2000, in which the black rate has dipped below 8 percent, in contrast to the fewer than four years in which the white rate has reached 8 percent. So, if 8 percent is a demarcation of economic calamity—as GOP pundits declared during the 2012 election cycle—then black Americans are in a perpetual state of employment crisis. And discrimination, of course, hardly ends when you find a job. The disparity between black and white wages has stagnated since the late 1970s and, for black women, even increased, while black family income has hovered right around 60 percent of white median income since the late 1960s.

The disparities are even larger when we examine wealth. Blacks and Latinos make up about 30 percent of the U.S. population, but collectively own about 5 percent of the nation’s wealth. When it comes to liquid assets, those that can be readily converted into cash, blacks and Latinos are virtually penniless. The typical black family has $200 in liquid non-housing and vehicle assets. And if you exclude retirement savings, they have $25 in the bank.

Meanwhile, in spite of these enormous disparities in capital stock, the prevailing discourse is focused on education, along with individual attitude, as the drivers of upward mobility. The presumption is that if black people were more responsible, made better financial decisions, and focused on education, they could get a good job and achieve economic security. But studying and working hard isn’t enough for black Americans. On average, if you are a white head of household that dropped out of high school, your family wealth is about $10,000 greater than that of a black family whose head graduated from college. If you are a black head of household employed full time, your family wealth is less than that of white families where the head is unemployed. And the typical middle-class black family has less wealth than the typical income-poor white family.

There is a clear intrinsic value to education, along with a public responsibility to offer everyone a high quality education. But education is not the antidote for the enormous racial disparities in wealth or employment. The societal over-emphasis on education as a panacea against racial and economic disparity directly follows from the dominant neoliberal, post-racial discourse. By largely ignoring the underlying structures of racial disparity, this empirically unsubstantiated rhetoric only serves to reinforce social hierarchy.

What we need instead are policies to eradicate the structural factors that preserve the relative status of dominant groups, including intergenerational resource transfers and exclusionary practices. One such policy—as William Darity, Jr., Alan Aja, Daniel Bustillo, and I have advocated in these pages—is a federal job guarantee, which would go a long way toward addressing racial disparities and building an inclusive U.S. economy. In addition to offering the economic security of a living wage to all citizens, the program would offer a wide array of public goods that this country desperately needs. Beyond physical infrastructure investments, like better transportation and clean energy, we also need more public investment in human infrastructure: schools, hospitals, the arts, and high-quality childcare. This public investment will provide tremendous economic benefit for the private sector as well. The Works Progress Administration (WPA) and Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) under the New Deal provide historical precedents where we had a great push in public sector works that stimulated the economy.

The federal job guarantee would set an implicit floor on wages, healthcare provisions, and any number of working conditions that employers would have to contend with if they want to attract workers. It would dramatically reduce the need for a minimum wage. And it would empower workers by removing the threat of unemployment, which leaves the working class with little to no bargaining power.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.