Reparations help whites rather than benefiting blacks
Darity, Lahiri, Frank Review of Development Economics 14(2), 248–261, 2010 DOI:10.1111/j.1467-9361.2010.00550.x Reparations for African-Americans as a Transfer Problem: A Cautionary tale William A. Darity, Jr., Bidisha Lahiri, and Dania V. Frank
The general-equilibrium model we advance offers new insights about the debate over reparations for African-Americans. First, we add to the discussion the idea that a reparations payment might enrich the donors. This sheds new light on arguments against reparations that claim that reparations payments would be too much of a burden for the payer to bear. It also provides a perverse incentive to the payer—other than altruism and atonement—to pay reparations. Second, and perhaps more important, this model provides a cautionary note towards the design of a reparations plan. If one believes that one important purpose of repa-rations is to bridge the income and/or wealth gap between blacks and nonblacks, then the way in which reparations are financed and carried out, as well as the economic conditions at the time of the payment, greatly affect success in achieving the goal. We have shown that if blacks do not have productive capacity in place prior to the repa-rations payment, there will be no ultimate effect on black income. We also have shown that reparations payment that either mandate or provide incentives for blacks to use the payment towards goods and services produced by nonblacks will increase the income of nonblacks while possibly decreasing the income of blacks. Both of these results run counter to the goal of closing the racial income gap. Black income will rise under a reparations program designed to induce blacks to spend largely on black commodities, while inducing nonblacks to finance the repara-tions payment primarily by reducing consumption of nonblack commodities. A reparations policy designed to improve the productive capacity of blacks also would increase the relative income of blacks but would impose a secondary burden or adverse terms-of-trade effect on blacks. Unless the latter effect is unusually large the net consequence of this type of program would be to close the gap. Thus, our paper uncovers some of the complexities of the effects of a reparations program and under-scores the importance of carefully considering the form reparations should take in order to achieve a narrowing of racial income or wealth disparities in America.