Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The aff exacerbates wealth disparities and inequities. Specific mandates need to be thought out

Frum 14 [David Frum is a senior editor at The Atlantic. In 2001–02, he was a speechwriter for President George W. Bush. “The impossibility of Reperations” https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/06/the-impossibility-of-reparations/372041/]

Affirmative action’s quirks and injustices are notorious. But they will be nothing compared to the strange consequences of a reparations program. Not all black people are poor. Not all non-black people are rich. Does Oprah have a housecleaner? Who changes the diapers of Beyonce’s baby? Who files Herman J. Russell’s taxes? Will their wages be taxed and the proceeds redirected to their employers? Within the target population, will all receive the same? Same per person, or same per family? Or will there be adjustment for need? How will need be measured? Will convicted criminals be eligible? If not, . If yes, the program would potentially tax victims of rape and families of the murdered for the benefit of their assailants. And if reparations were somehow delivered communally and collectively, disparities of wealth and power and political influence within black America will become even more urgent. Simply put, when government spends money on complex programs, the people who provide the service usually end up with much more sway over the spending than the spending’s intended beneficiaries. The poorer the beneficiaries, the more powerfully this rule holds—and it has held strongest of all in programs intended to aid the black poor. The District of Columbia public schools have excelled at delivering stable jobs to their unionized employees. They have failed their students.

The reparations movement faces significant problems in trying to name people who have a legitimate claim against individual defendants. There are no slaves alive today who can bring suit, and there are no slave-owners who can be sued. This is a distinct difference between reparations for slavery and reparations paid to Japanese Americans or to victims of the Holocaust. Here, proponents cannot show direct harm. Instead, they are seeking to have the government pay reparations to individuals who are several generations removed from slavery. They claim that the United States government has never acknowledged or apologized for the evil institution of slavery. Black Americans deserve payment for the wealth slave labor created, they continue. 6 8 When opponents point out that both slaves and enslavers are long dead, proponents have an answer. The government must, they contend," pay for the "lingering effects," "vestiges" or "legacy" of slavery that, they claim, still affect black America today.69 However, it is impossible to determine whether a link exists between slavery and the problems facing Blacks today. For example, reparations proponents bludgeon the opposition into submission with a wealth of data about poverty, infant mortality rates, health care and the number of black men in the prison system.7° However, many of these problems have only surfaced within the last forty years and cannot be traced directly to slavery. In addition, there is no way to accurately identify who were descendants of slaves and those of slave-owners. Generations of people were bom who belonged to both groups. Our nation today is a eflection of many different cultures and ethnicities coalescing into one "melting pot." As a result, asking for reparations based solely on the fact that a person is black actually perpetuates the same racism that proponents vigorously argue to curtail. It would be unfair to penalize and simultaneously reward reparations to people today when our history is incredibly convoluted. Reparationists refuse to acknowledge that slavery had a negative impact on everyone. Reparations advocates will give short shrift to white poverty, perhaps even denying that slavery was meant to, and in fact did, impoverish the masses of white people as much as it did the Blacks. Soon, everyone will want reparations, even neo-Confederates who cherish their ancestors who fought to preserve slavery. This petition does not mention the South's enslavement of millions of Blacks, its deliberate impoverishment of and mis-education of the masses of Whites and Blacks or of its cramming the Fugitive Slave Law, which resulted in some free Blacks who were never slaves being kidnapped and sold, down the throats of an unwilling nation. There is not a hint that Southerners were in any way to blame for the fate that befell them. Here we see the likeness of minds of the neoConfederate and the black reparations supporter. Both embrace perpetual victim hood. Both claim to still suffer the agony inflicted not on themselves, but on ancestors long since dead. Neither is able to put what happened over 135 years ago behind them

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.