Cooperation is more expensive – public sector requires at least 24% extra capital to account for risk
Hall 8 (David, Director @ Public Services International Research Unit, Business Scholl @ U of Greenwich, www.psiru.org/reports/2008-11-PPPs-crit.doc)JFS [note: PPP is public private partnership]
But the construction element of PPP projects is much more expensive. An EIB report compared the cost of PPP road projects across Europe with conventionally procured road projects, and found that the PPPs were on average 24% more expensive than the public sector roads. 72 In 2007 the Polish government cancelled a motorway PPP for exactly this reason: they realised that the A1 Motorway from Grudziadz-Torun could be built for about €5.6m. per kilometre using conventional procurement, compared with €7.4m. per km. using the PPP. 73 The EIB report also notes that this premium of 24% is about the same as estimates of cost overruns on public procurement projects, and so the extra cost of PPP projects reflects the payment required by the contractor to accept construction risk.