States EITC expansion solves UBI – A expansion of state Earned Income Tax credit (EITC) would be able to act as guaranteed income to low income communities
Downey, Legal Impact Network at the Shiver Center, Staff Attorney, et al., 22
(Nolan, Jeremy Rosen, Shiver Center staff, Marie Claire Tran-Leung, Shiver Center staff, Michelle Nicolet, Shiver Center staff, Emily Coffey, Shiver Center staff, Marcus Samuel, Shiver Center staff, Dina Kostrow, Shiver Center staff, Gabriela Camargo Martins, Economic Security Project staff, Michael Conti, Economic Security Project staff, Andrea Diaz, Economic Security Project staff, Pedro Morillas, Economic Security Project staff, Madeline Neighly, Economic Security Project staff, April 2022, Shiver Center on Poverty Law, and Economic Security Project, “States Lead the Way in Reimagining the Social Safety Net”, , Accessed 7-2-23, ED)
State Considerations:
Implementation
Strategies
As states consider the creation of a large-scale, publicly funded guaranteed income program, they need to choose how to implement the program. Implementation strategies do not merely affect overall program cost and administration, but they are also highly relevant in determining how publicly funded guaranteed income payments interact with other means-tested public benefits.
States can choose to adopt one of the following implementation strategies:
• Use the tax system by implementing or expanding a state Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) or Earned Income Credit (EIC).
• Create an invested public sovereign wealth fund and declare periodic dividends for eligible households (similar to Alaska’s program).
• Construct robust new infrastructure to administer the program, or, at the very least, integrate the program into existing benefit distribution processes.
Expanding State Earned Income Tax Credit
The federal Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) is a refundable tax credit for working families created in 1975 by the Ford Administration. Its aim was to shield low-wage workers from the regressive effects of rising payroll taxes and to provide an additional income boost for workers near or below the poverty line.43 While the majority of an individual’s EITC comes from their federal tax return, thirty states, the District of Columbia, and a few municipalities44 have established their own EITCs to supplement the federal credit.45
Similar to the recently expanded federal Child Tax Credit, what distinguishes the federal EITC from many other credits in the tax code is its ”refundability,” meaning the full amount of the credit is given to low- income workers as cash, rather than merely reducing their tax liability. In 2018, the federal EITC lifted roughly 5.6 million people out of poverty, including about 3 million children. A state approach that modifies and bolsters a state EITC to achieve a functional guaranteed income for low-income people is an attractive proposition because it both comes with an existing mechanism to get payments to recipients, and those payments have a stronger basis for exemption from consideration as income in other benefits programs
like SNAP and TANF.
$1,600
Average annual amount paid to Alaska residents from the Permanent Fund Dividend Program since 1980
Source: Alaska Permanent Fund Corporation (APFC)
Unfortunately, the current federal EITC framework does not provide the full credit to households that do not meet the minimum threshold of earnings to qualify, excluding the lowest wage earning and non-wage earning households. Additionally, some groups like unpaid caregivers and domestic workers, as well as immigrants who file taxes with an Individual Tax ID number are not able to access these valuable credits. A state could create an efficient avenue to a functional guaranteed income for a large swath of a state’s population by enacting reforms to the state EITC that:
• Is fully refundable, ensuring that extremely low- and no-income families are eligible,
• Expands the state’s federal match rate to provide recipients with greater support,
• Raises income eligibility thresholds to extend eligibility to some middle-income earners, and
• Provide access to immigrants and other previously excluded groups.46