States act more promptly
Hays, Professor of Law, Columbia University School of Law, 1954
[Paul R., Jun. 1954, University of Pennsylvania Law Review, “Federalism and Labor Relations in the United States,” https://www.jstor.org/stable/3309892, Accessed 07/09/2023, BS]
There are also basic problems which may be called sociological.
However narrowly the policy of the NLRA is defined in terms of pre- venting interruptions to the free flow of commerce, actually it must be looked upon in a much larger way as free enterprise's answer to social- ism. It assures the freedom of the worker to organize, to increase his bargaining power and to participate in the determination of his own economic destiny. And by giving him this status it gives him the opportunity to better his economic condition instead of granting him benefits directly through the machinery of government. But control and regulation of this power are as necessary with respect to the or- ganizations of labor as they are with respect to the organizations of capital. The problem of federalism is, then, what part the federal government and what part the states should play in protecting and in limiting these rights.
In the decision of these basic questions there is the need to con- sider the problem of effective administration of standards. Which gov- ernment is better able to achieve results which both are seeking? In some particulars the answer is obvious. For example, effective con- trol of violence in connection with labor disputes is going to continue to be the duty of the state merely because Congress is not going to create a national police force for this purpose. Such a conclusion can be thought of as arising from basic assumptions of the federalist system itself. But there are other problems to be solved in empirical terms. State labor relations boards where they exist have, in general, acted more promptly and, therefore, more effectively, than has the National Board. Are there not some aspects of the labor relations picture where prompt and effective action is more important than that the action