State by state $15 Minimum-Wage would reduce employment
VerBruggen, Editor for National Review and fellow at Manhattan Institute , ‘21
[Robert, 3/8/2021, National Review,, “Minimum-Wage Complexities,” https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=148761436&site=ehost-live&scope=site , Accessed 07/07/2023, BS]
DEMOCRATS are moving fast to advance some of their biggest policy goals under the guise of COVID-19 relief. One of their most contentious proposals is to increase the minimum wage to $15 an hour by 2025, with the phase-in beginning this year.
That is an exceedingly risky idea. It could reduce employment by more than a million jobs. And the effects would reverberate well beyond the employment impact, because minimum-wage hikes have a variety of convoluted, poorly understood, and unpredictable knock-on effects. If we want higher wages at the bottom of the labor market, there are better ways to create them.
Let's start with those employment effects, which are easily the most debated aspect of the minimum wage. Basic economics suggests that when the government dictates a price floor for something—in this case, an hour of labor—fewer people will want to buy it. Someone might be willing to hire extra workers or boost hours if he's paying $10 an hour, but not if he's paying $15, in which case he'd prefer to invest in something else, such as machines. Everyone agrees this will become a big problem at some point, which is why no one suggests a minimum wage of $100 an hour.
What's disputed is exactly how strong this effect is at lower minimum-wage levels. Some studies suggest that minimum wages of half or even two-thirds of the median wage might not produce measurable employment drops. Even taking these findings at face value, however, we start to see some problems with a $15 minimum. The median wage in the U.S. was just $19.14 in 2019. In some states, to say nothing of rural counties, it was far lower: Mississippi had a median wage of $15 on the nose, meaning about half of workers would need raises to comply with a $15 minimum.
And we should not take those "no effect on employment" findings at face value, because they do not represent the academic literature as a whole. In a recent review, David Neumark and Peter Shirley gathered several decades' worth of work and found "a clear preponderance of negative estimates," especially in research that focused on teens, young adults, those with low education, and workers specifically affected by minimum-wage hikes. The Con gressional Budget Office has arrived at the same conclusion, averaging the results of various studies to project that a $15 minimum wage would reduce employment by nearly 1 percent, or 1.4 million jobs.
Further, regardless of whether em ployment declines, someone has to pay the higher wages. On the question of exactly who pays, there's even less consensus than there is on employment effects. But in a recent article, the economist Jeffrey Clemens took a tour of what we do know about how firms deal with the new expense.
The hope of minimum-wage advo cates is that these wages will simply come out of profits, making the minimum wage a clean transfer from business owners to low-earning workers. To some extent this happens, especially in industries where busi nesses have few other margins on which to adjust—though if profits are slim to begin with, trying to absorb a wage increase could just mean going out of business. But lots of firms do have other options.
For one thing, about 30 percent of compensation in this country takes the form of benefits rather than wages and salaries. So when wages go up by government fiat, businesses can make benefits less generous to cancel out at least some of the mandatory raise. Businesses can also take away all sorts of perks and comforts to squeeze more value out of each hour of work they pay for: make schedules less flexible, super vise workers more closely and demand more effort, stop providing free snacks, cut investments in worker safety, etc., etc. There's some evidence that employers do respond in such ways, but the topic hasn't been studied nearly enough.