Federal fiscal policy makes the states too dependent on the federal government – undermines federalism
Edwards, Cato, state tax and budget issues top expert, 22
(Chris, 2022, CATO Institute, “Fiscal Federalism”, , Accessed 7-3-23, ED)
Under the U.S. Constitution, the federal government was assigned specific, limited powers, and most government functions were left to the states. To emphasize the limits on federal power, the nation’s Founders added the Tenth Amendment: “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.” The amendment embodies federalism, the idea that federal and state governments have separate policy areas and that federal activities are “few and defined,” as James Madison noted in Federalist no. 45.
The federal government generally kept out of state and local fiscal affairs until the mid‐20th century. But since then, Congress has increasingly intervened with “grant‐in‐aid” programs, which are subsidies to the states coupled with top‐down regulations. Today, there are more than 1,300 federal aid programs for education, housing, health care, highways, transit, and many other activities.
Federal aid to the states totaled $721 billion in 2019. Then Congress boosted aid enormously during the pandemic to $829 billion in 2020, $1.25 trillion in 2021, and an estimated $1.23 trillion in 2022. These are fiscal years. As it turned out, most of this aid was not needed because state and local tax revenues have grown strongly the past two years, providing governments the resources to handle the crisis.
The states have become far too dependent on federal aid. State governments are not regional subdivisions of the federal government. The aid system generates excessive spending, creates costly bureaucracy, reduces political accountability, stifles diversity, and undermines local democratic control. The following discussion explores nine reasons why federal aid should be cu