Environmental federalism solves climate change through maximizing regulatory effectiveness, spurring innovation, and catalyzing concrete action
Buzbee Georgetown Law’s Environmental Law & Policy Program, Faculty Director 17 (William W., 2017, Wisconsin Law Review, “Federalism Hedging, Entrenchment, and the Climate Challenge”, https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3368&context=facpub, ccm)
As with other regulatory challenges characterized by rapid change, innovation, and turbulent politics, retaining state and local climate authority both intertwined with and possibly independent from federal climate regulation would create a more sturdy and resilient web of regulation, stabilize linked markets, and discourage efforts to derail a federal climate law. The mere possibility of more state regulation would create heightened incentives for successful federal regulation that would, in turn, reduce potentially disparate state measures. With more regulatory stability, market rewards for innovation would also be enhanced.
Federal climate preemption and unitary regulatory scheme arguments may make sense in an idealized world of perfect, stable legal commitments, but in a real world pervaded by regulatory failure, reversal risks, and political instability, such unitary preemptive regimes would undercut climate progress. The more federal climate regulation or future legislation uses preemptive strategies, the more all hopes for climate progress would rest on one imperfect and vulnerable federal vessel. Retaining room for state and local climate regulation and linked clean energy efforts hedges regulatory risks. Such overlapping and potentially intertwined federal and state regulation may, somewhat paradoxically, be the most effective way to ensure that a future federal climate law or regulation under existing law will actually be implemented and endure despite ongoing political and legal contestation.
In the meantime, during times of federal policy reversal or inertia, the enduring norm of room for additional state regulation and innovation remains important. States, alongside intermittent federal progress and policy support, have been critical to climate and clean energy progress and in catalyzing federal climate engagement. During a period of federal recoil, states will again likely become the main vessel for climate momentum and in rewarding clean energy innovation. Through that retained and ongoing state authority, the pressure will build for federal reengagement. Through the benefits of federalism hedging, climate progress may slow but is unlikely to cease.