Can’t solve econ – State fiscal redistribution welfare spending hurts econ, the federal government is needed to provide funding
Chernick, Hunter College, Professor of Economics, 10
(Howard, 2010, SAGE, “Redistribution at the State and Local Level: Consequences for Economic Growth”, DOI: 10.1177/1091142110375694, Accessed 7-9-23, ED)
Conclusion
The compensating differential model of wage determination predicts that greater fiscal redistribution will be capitalized in higher wages for high- skilled workers, leading to an increase in the relative cost of production and a potential decline in employment and output. This negative effect may be offset by differences across states in preferences for redistribution, and by positive human capital effects from redistributional spending. Economic growth provides an efficient summary of these various effects. I estimate a reduced form model of the effect of subnational redistribution on the rate of growth in state income.
Redistribution is measured by tax progressivity, spending on welfare and higher education, and the state share of elementary and secondary education spending. Table 8 provides a summary of results. In contrast to conven- tional wisdom, the degree of progressivity of state and local taxes does not affect economic growth. However, while own progressivity has no effect, I find a modest but statistically significant positive effect for neighbor pro- gressivity, suggesting the existence of fiscal spillovers across states. The implication is that a state that serves as a regional tax haven for higher income taxpayers realizes a small but measurable growth dividend as a con- sequence of its neighbors’ fiscal choices. The fact that own-state growth is not adversely affected by tax progressivity helps to explain the persistence of differentiated tax structures within regions. A leading example is the way in which New Hampshire, with a highly regressive tax structure, adjoins much more progressive Vermont and Massachusetts.
Most of the variables measuring expenditure redistribution are insignif- icant. In contrast to previous studies, higher welfare spending has no affect on the rate of growth in per capita income. However, aggregate income growth, particularly over five-year periods, is negatively related to higher welfare spending. Because aggregate income growth and population growth are strongly correlated, the welfare effect on aggregate income growth is almost identical to its effect on population growth. The result is consistent with studies of the effect of fiscal factors on the migration patterns of the elderly. The negative effect of welfare spending on aggregate, as opposed to per capita income growth, may indicate that low-skilled workers are more responsive than high-skilled workers to cost-of-living differentials associated with differences in welfare spending. The differential fiscal effects of higher welfare spending are consistent with regional growth studies stressing the distinction between job growth and income growth (Florida 2005).
Federal cost sharing for redistribution, through tax deductibility and intergovernmental aid, serves to diminish interstate fiscal differentials and may therefore help to attenuate negative growth effects of redistributive fis- cal policies. Hence, it is noteworthy that welfare spending shows a negative effect on aggregate economic growth, despite the fact that the federal gov- ernment provides over half of all welfare funding.
The state share of school spending is a proxy for fiscal equalization and is associated with the uniformity of per-pupil spending. In some specifica- tions, the state share of school spending has a negative effect on growth. However, the result is not sufficiently robust to derive policy conclusions. Higher education spending has no effect on any of the growth measures, although there is some evidence of positive spillover effects in aggregate growth to geographic neighbors.
In summary, fiscal redistribution does not exhibit statistically robust effects on economic growth. Although the effects on labor supply (and land rents) may work in the direction predicted by the compensating differential model, any such adjustments are insufficient to affect per capita income. The only robust negative effect is that of welfare spending on aggregate income growth. If anything, this result suggests that low-skilled workers are more responsive to fiscal differentials than higher skilled workers.