Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Uncooperative federalism fails – creates inefficiencies, race to the bottom, and decreases the government’s ability to respond

Parmet, Northeastern University's Center for Health Policy and Law, Co-Director, 22

(Wendy E., 11-19-22, Scientific American, “Fights between U.S. States and the National Government Are Endangering Public Health”, , Accessed 7-8-23, ED)

Still, many Americans cling to the nostalgic notion that the protection of health belongs primarily to the states, territories and tribal jurisdictions. In the early months of the COVID pandemic, then-President Trump expressed that view, telling governors that they were going to call their “own shots.” That’s a sentiment that the conservative justices of the Supreme Court seemed to share last June when they limited EPA’s ability to address climate change and overturned Roe v. Wade.

There are times when it makes sense to leave health policy to the states. Some health threats are truly local. Consider an unsanitary restaurant. It probably doesn’t require a nationwide solution. By leaving restaurant inspections to states and local governments, the public is more likely to be protected against unsafe meals. Likewise, states and local governments are in a far better position than the federal government to provide many on-the-ground health services, from sexually transmitted disease clinics to tuberculosis screenings. The day-to-day work of public health departments depends in large measure on their placement in and relationships with local communities.

States, territories, and tribal government can also serve as “laboratories of democracy,” to borrow Justice Louis Brandeis’ term. They can develop innovative health policies that other governments and even the federal government can copy. For example, Massachusetts 2006 health care reform law served as the model for the federal Affordable Care Act. States and cities have also led the way in tobacco control, banning youth access and indoor smoking years before the federal government made a serious effort to reduce cigarette consumption.

Policy differences between jurisdictions can also serve as a type of a natural experiment, from which policy makers can learn which laws work and which don’t. Researchers can look at how varying motor vehicle safety laws in different states or different childhood vaccine laws correlate with motor vehicular accidents and vaccination respectively. Much of what we know about the efficacy of health policies comes precisely from such studies.

Unfortunately, the cry for “states’ rights” today often ends up endangering health, just as it did by perpetuating the systematic racial oppression that underlies so many of today’s health inequities. To see how federalism threatens health, consider the early days of the COVID pandemic. Although states could and did implement many measures that slowed the coronavirus in 2020, they could not prevent the transmission of the microbe across state lines. One state’s lax policies invariably led to increases in cases in other states. The divergent approaches by different state governments in 2020 and 2021 also muddied the public health message. (To be fair, the poor messaging from the federal government did not help.) For example, it was hard to know in the summer and fall of 2020 if masking was beneficial when only some states required it. Worse, the variation in policies among states created a type of race to the bottom in which the economic competition from states with looser regulations pushed other states to rescind their own health orders. (Interestingly, states that kept restrictions in place longer had better health outcomes, but faced worse economic conditions).

The need for a national response has also been evident during the monkeypox outbreak. One of the major stumbling blocks to containing the disease last summer was a shortfall of reliable data. But due to constitutional limitations and the norms that have grown up around them, the federal government depends on the states, territories and tribal authorities to gather and share data about disease outbreaks, as well as for much of the frontline response, as Secretary of Health and Human Services Xavier Becerra noted in excusing the federal government’s inability to get on top of the escalating outbreak. While Becerra’s statement was largely self-serving, he was correct in stating that the federal government’s capacity to respond to a pandemic depends, in large measure, on the cooperation of the states, territories, and tribal authorities.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.