Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

No link and turn - cooperative federalism solves environmental problems

Ryan, Florida State University School of Law, Professor of Law, 2015 [Erin, 2015, Environment and Society, Chapter entitled “Environmental Federalism’s Tug of War Within” in the book by Kalyani Robins, ed., THE LAW AND POLICY OF ENVIRONMENTAL FEDERALISM: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS (Edward Elgar, 2015), http://www.environmentandsociety.org/sites/default/files/key_docs/environmental_federalisms_tug_of_war_within_ssrn_2.pdf, /MB]

B. The Tools of Cooperative Environmental Federalism. Interjurisdictional environmental problems cannot be managed exclusively at the local or national level, because they require governance capacity from the full spectrum of governance scale. 212 For that reason, cooperative environmental federalism models strive to partner the needed elements that tend to be superior at the federal level with elements that are usually superior at the state and local level, ideally through processes that empower each level to perform to their strengths.

Federally superior governance capacity often includes, inter alia: scientific, technical, and financial resources; the legal authority to enforce nationally uniform standards; the ability to appropriately scale regulation for large-scale public commons; and the ability to police spillover effects from one autonomously acting state to another. Elements of governance capacity that tend to be superior at the state and local level often include: detailed expertise about local environmental, geographic, economic, demographic, political, and cultural factors that bear on the needs and workability of regulatory proposals; locally situated enforcement personnel; the legal authority to regulate local land use and engage in comprehensive land use planning; and other police power-based legal authority to regulate beyond the more limited set of federally enumerated powers. (Of course, these generalizations bear exceptions.) Governance that skillfully partners complementary capacity across levels enhances the regulatory voice of each, harnessing synergy in a way that belies the old zero-sum federalism game.

Intergovernmental partnerships may involve direct state-federal coordination, but they are often mediated by statutory structures that asymmetrically allocate decision-making authority within programs of coordinated capacity, federally-supported state implementation, conditional preemption, and shared and general permitting programs. Each of these methods strives to maximize local and national authority where each can best contribute, and many have been pioneered by environmental law.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.