No Internal Link – Courts have power over congress now
Parmet, Northeastern University's Center for Health Policy and Law, Co-Director, 22
(Wendy E., 11-19-22, Scientific American, “Fights between U.S. States and the National Government Are Endangering Public Health”, , Accessed 7-8-23, ED)
These inefficiencies have been amplified by more than two decades of Supreme Court decisions that, in the name of states’ rights, have handcuffed the federal government’s ability to protect the public’s health. For example, in 1997, the Supreme Court ruled that the federal government could not command state officials to conduct background checks before gun sales. That decision explains why the federal government could not require the states to open or close schools during the pandemic, or require states to impose vaccination requirements. While the federal government can use its spending powers to induce states to comply with its policy goals, states can reject the money and refuse to cooperate.
The Supreme Court underscored that point, while emphasizing states’ rights in its 2012 decision in NFIB v. Sebelius, which blocked the federal government’s efforts through the Affordable Care Act to expand Medicaid. The result: more than two million more Americans were left uninsured. The goal of preserving the states’ primary role over health also played a crucial rule in the Supreme Court’s 2021 ruling striking CDC’s eviction moratorium, a policy the agency had intended to prevent people from losing their homes during the pandemic. The Supreme Court later relied on that case to block the Occupational Safety and Health Administration’s rule mandating that large employers require their employees to be vaccinated or wear a mask and be tested. A few months later, the Court cited those decisions to strike down EPA’s Clean Power Plan rule. Lower courts have relied on these cases to enjoin federal COVID vaccine mandates for federal contractors, federal employees and even Head Start childcare programs.
The impact of the Court’s decisions is magnified in our current polarized and often dysfunctional political landscape in which Congress and the states often choose not to cooperate with the federal government, or even sister states, regardless of the health consequences. Indeed, the various structural limits that the Court has erected to protect states’ rights have come to serve as a tool that partisans use to attack the policies of federal leaders from the opposing party. Hence, we have the increasingly frequent practice of red states rushing to court to challenge the policies of Democratic presidents, and blue states bringing lawsuits against Republican presidents. How else to explain the fact that 22 states brought lawsuits challenging a vaccine mandate for federal contractors? With the courts’ assent, if not invitation, federalism has become but another weapon for partisan warriors. With that, health policies languish and public well-being declines.
The deleterious impact of our polarized environment has also spurred battles among the states. During the early days of the pandemic, several states threatened to block travel from residents of other states. States also engaged in a bidding war for the procurement of critical supplies in spring 2020. Such intrastate strife has only escalated since the Supreme Court issued its decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Center, overturning Roe v. Wade. In theory, the Supreme Court’s decision should allow each state to go its own way. But this live-and-let-live attitude may not be viable with an issue as deeply contentious as abortion (as it was not with slavery or Jim Crow). Predictably, in the months since Dobbs was decided, we have seen the type of interstate battles that we have not seen since the Civil War, as states banning abortion have threatened to block interstate travel and criminalize procedures done in other states, while states permitting abortion rushed to pass laws protecting their clinicians from out-of-state prosecution. Meanwhile, the federal government and the states are also engaged in litigation about whether federal protections for patients in emergency departments supersedes state bans on abortion. And advocates on both sides of the issue seek a federal law codifying their position. In short, despite frequent paeans to federalism, neither side is willing to accept the diversity of approaches that federalism should entail.