The environment impact is backwards – devolving to the states is worse for environmental protection
Blundell, School of Economic Sciences at Washington State University, Assistant Professor, et al. 21[Wesley, Mary F. Evans, Jerrine and Thomas Mitchell ‘66 Professor of Environmental Economics and George R. Roberts Fellow in the Robert Day School of Economics and Finance at Claremont McKenna College, Sarah L. Stafford, Ph.D. in Economics, Chancellor Professor of Economics and Department Chair, July 2021, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, Volume 108, “Regulating hazardous wastes under U.S. environmental federalism: The role of state resources”, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeem.2021.102464, ccm]
We also find evidence that budget-constrained states decrease the number of resource-intensive on-site inspections at large RCRA facilities while increasing the number of lower-cost off-site inspections. Many of the off-site inspections are records reviews, which determine whether the facility has met the regulatory requirements for financial or other types of record keeping. Such inspections may be less effective in detecting regulatory violations that would have a direct impact on human health and the environment than on-site compliance evaluations. If so, then a potential worrisome consequence of this substitution is poorer environmental outcomes in states with shrinking environmental budgets.
Due to data limitations on monitoring and enforcement efforts at small quantity generators and other “non-large” RCRA facilities, we are unable to examine the impacts of decreases in state budgets at those facilities. However, given that there is no formal guidance, minimum standards, or oversight on monitoring at these facilities, it seems likely that decreases in state budgets would have similar, if not greater, impacts on agency efforts towards them. While one might be tempted to dismiss such impacts at these “non-large” facilities as being inconsequential, given the large number of such facilities (over 300,000 across the U.S.) the aggregate effect on environmental quality could be substantial.
Under the Trump administration there was significant devolution of responsibility for environmental protection to states. In 2018, EPA administrator Andrew Wheeler stated that “States and tribes have the primary role in state- and tribalimplemented federal programs, and the EPA will generally defer to states and tribes in their day-to-day activities” (Wheeler, 2018). It is unclear whether this trend will continue under the Biden administration or whether we will see a reversal. The results of our analysis suggest the potential for further decreases in state environmental monitoring and enforcement efforts and a consequent decrease in environmental quality in some areas if the Biden Administration were to continue to devolve program responsibility to states without increasing federal grant funding for state programs. Additionally, given significant existing differences in state environmental budgets, that could lead to increasing heterogeneity in environmental outcomes across states.