Racism is an inherent part of income inequality – UBI helps mitigate the effects of distorted wealth accumulation and concurrent prejudice
Iannuzzi & Oishi, Assistant and Professor of Phycology, 21
(Jazmin Brown Iannuzzi, assistant professor at the University of Virginia, Shigehiro Oishi, professor of psychology at the University of Virginia, Racial Inequality at the Brink: How Economic Inequality Exacerbates Racial Prejudice and the Potential Alleviating Role of a Universal Basic Income”, https://www.russellsage.org/sites/default/files/racialprej_LOI_example.pdf-grh)
In the U.S., both economic inequality and racial economic inequality – or the unequal distribution of financial resources across racial groups – is large and growing. From 1983 to 2016, the median White family went from approximately 8 times to 13 times more wealth than the median Black family (Pew, 2016). More recently, the pandemic has left Black families more vulnerable to death by COVID-19 and its economic shocks (Hardy & Logan, 2020; Wrigley-Field, 2020). Making matters worse, data suggest that income inequality precedes rises in White-on-Black racial prejudice (Connor et al., 2019; see also Hovland & Sears, 1940). Unfortunately, little empirical data investigates how inequality impacts individuals’ psychological processing and, in turn, increases prejudice. And, almost no work investigates the impact of inequality on racial minorities (Bianchi, 2020). Critically, inequality could also exacerbate prejudice between low-social power groups, stifling coalition building across these groups. The global pandemic’s widening of economic inequality makes now a crucial moment for understanding how inequality may exacerbate prejudice and for developing effective strategies to mitigate this process’s dire outcomes. The current application (1) puts forth a new hypothesis: inequality group-competition hypothesis, and (2) examines whether a policy, such as universal basic income, could mitigate the impact of inequality on prejudice (see Figure 1). We hypothesize that higher inequality triggers beliefs that people are in competition for limited resources because people tend to think the economy is zero-sum, meaning that one person’s higher earnings implies others’ lower earnings (Friedman & Friedman, 1990; related work see Buttrick & Oishi, 2017; Sommet et al., 2017). Perceiving others as competitors for scarce resources increases individuals’ concerns about their individual position and their groups’ position within society (Elliot, 2006; Esses et al., 2001). Status concerns activate both the desire to gain more resources for the self and group, as well as fear of losing relative position in the socioeconomic hierarchy (e.g., Davidai & Ongis, 2019; Sommet et al., 2017). Further, because inequality fosters the mindset of living in an intensely competitive environment, residents may be particularly attuned to group membership cues, such as race, as a way to determine whether someone has the potential to be economically beneficial (because they are ingroup member) or harmful (because they are an outgroup member). Providing for basic needs via a universal basic income may mitigate the impact of higher inequality on increasing prejudice by assuaging people’s zero-sum biases and their fears that others are competing for limited resources. However, to whom basic income is provided must be carefully considered to mitigate resentment toward a specific income and racial group.