Growth is incompatible with the survival of the biosphere. It is the root cause driving mass species extinction.
Moranta et al, Senior researcher at the Ecosystem Oceanography Group, 2021
[Joan, “Transcending capitalism growth strategies for biodiversity conservation” Conservation Biology, 18 August 2021, https://conbio.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/cobi.13821#cobi13821-bib-0060 Accessed 7/15/2023 GDI-HB]
We suggest conservationists liaise with political ecologists and ecological economists to underline the problems and contradictions in the relationship between growth and biodiversity. We argue here that capitalism's metabolism is not compatible with an economy that respects the limits of the biosphere. The negative impact of economic growth on biodiversity is evident in the literature, and environmental and biodiversity conservation programs grounded in economic growth are ineffective. To ensure growth, continuous extraction of value from and commodification of nature is required to safeguard the capital, which in itself constitutes one of the most critical contradictions of capitalism. A capitalist economy not only exhausts the material basis for its reproduction, but also deteriorates the biophysical conditions that enable life on Earth (Foster et al., 2010; Harvey, 2014; Moore, 2015). Capitalism's commodification of nature and its derived conservation policies, such as payments for ecosystem services and biodiversity offsets, will result in perpetuating the growth-based status quo.
By synthesizing the main findings of the existing research on the contradictions between growth and biodiversity conservation, we add to the conservation science literature an important argument to take into account during the negotiations of the post-2020 GBF. One of the main challenges to be faced by society in the 21st century is not biodiversity conservation itself but the need to restructure the current socioeconomic metabolism in such a way it is not driven by the logic of profit and growth through the destruction of nature and human lives. If this is not done, it will be difficult to stop biodiversity loss and ecosystem destruction and the resulting environmental and social damages. It is necessary to urgently reconvert the socioeconomic system into one that pursues an ecologically and socially healthier society.
The socioecological crisis demands urgent transformative action (Díaz et al., 2019; IPBES–IPCC, 2021) to move humanity away from the paradigm of economic growth, as stated in emerging research on nongrowth-oriented social transformation in the conservation literature. Büscher et al. (2017a) postulate that “we need to recognize that it is ultimately economic growth itself that is the root cause of biodiversity loss and hence to take the possibilities of degrowth economics seriously.” Büscher and Fletcher (2020) develop revolutionary ideas for conservation that help one think and completely reframe the question of biodiversity conservation. They state that “if conservation is tied to capitalism and capitalism necessitates growth, then degrowth, in its more radical incarnation, means moving beyond capitalism and hence should have profound consequences for conservation.” Fletcher, Massarella, et al. (2020) propose a global green new deal for conservation grounded in the need for an overarching structural shift to a postgrowth society that “given capitalism's systemic imperative to incessant growth requires the liberating prospect of transcending capitalism, as well as the statism and patriarchy with which it is associated.” Sandbrook et al. (2020) argue for a post-COVID, transformative, economic reconstruction that questions growth; involves adopting a long-term vision; and accepts short-term costs, such as losing some conservation funds, projects, and even organizations dependent on unsustainable aspects of the pre-COVID-19 economic model. Otero et al. (2020) propose a nongrowth scenario to support this transition and “recommend that in the negotiations of the next CBD Conference of the Parties and in future assessments of the IPBES, endorsement of economic growth is replaced by at least a precautionary recognition that it can be problematic for biodiversity.” In turn, IPBES states that the focus of their work is not on a single scenario but on a diversity of human–nature relationships and positive visions of the future post-2020 framework that ultimately enables transformative change (Lundquist et al., 2021).