Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

And, Current construction of jobs versus the environment ensures dependency on unsustainable while individual workers internalize the extractivist discourse within communities

Lawhon, Assistant Professor of Geography and Environmental Sustainability at the University of Oklahoma, and McCreary, Assistant Professor at the Department of Geography at Florida State University, 2020

[Mary and Tyler, “Beyond Jobs vs Environment: On the Potential of Universal Basic Income to Reconfigure Environmental Politics” Antipode, 28 January 2020, https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/anti.12604, Accessed 7/13/2023 GDI-HB]

Political conflicts between jobs and the environment remain trenchant as sociotechnical and environmental change exacerbate concerns about both disemployment and ecological collapse. Of course, at the global scale and in the long run, sustainability and livelihoods are not at odds: viable livelihoods are predicated on a sustainable earth. For specific individuals and job sectors in particular locations, however, environmental protection often conflicts with established ways of making a living. We argue therefore that the “jobs vs the environment” problematique is best understood through a geographical lens as a specific, located conflict. Various strategies have been put forward to mitigate this conflict, ranging from job training and relocation to support for local economies and worker ownership, yet these strategies remain constrained by the entanglement of income, labour, and local development.

We argue that enacting a universal basic income (UBI)—the public provision of every individual with enough money to meet their basic needs—can transform the horizon of contemporary environmental politics. UBI is a capacious concept with both neoliberal and progressive versions. We focus here on the utility for environmental politics of a UBI that reworks the politics of distribution but does not replace or reduce the state; in such a vision, the state remains active in the provisioning of public goods. While a UBI is not a panacea that solves socioecological contradictions or substitutes for the contentious processes that make radical politics happen, we consider UBI as a useful demand and tool in the struggle for different, better futures. Our central contention is that a progressive UBI has the potential to subtend an emergent environmental politics that addresses livelihoods and sustainability through reconfiguring the nexus of income, labour, and development. We are inspired by our own research on waste in South Africa (Mary Lawhon) and extractive industries in Canada (Tyler McCreary), but seek to make arguments with wider relevance.

In what follows, we first position our argument within scholarship on the jobs vs environment problematique and ongoing studies of UBI. We then examine the extent to which the enactment of a progressive UBI is complementary to prominent leftist approaches that rework the relationship between the environment and economy. We argue that a UBI has the potential to delink labour, income, and development, helping create the conditions of possibility for the emergence of alternative subjectivities. Further, through freeing people from drudgerous labour, a UBI frees time, opening political opportunities for people to participate in the much needed but time-consuming work of rebuilding our communities and our democracies in ways that enable us to realise our collective interest in sustainability.

Locating the Jobs vs the Environment Problematique

The jobs vs the environment problematique has roots in a range of different environmental conflicts. Environmentalists’ concerns of the 1960s and 1970s with global South issues such as desertification and deforestation were often cast as stymying southern economic development (and the jobs it could produce) (Adams 1990; Redclift 1984; WCED 1987). The global environmental justice movement too has been concerned with conflicts between jobs and the environment (Agyeman 2005; Bullard 1993, 2000). While the environmental justice movement sought to integrate economic and environmental health issues, it was often inhibited by impacted communities’ economic dependence on contaminating industries. Facing campaigns for new occupational health and safety codes and environmental regulations, companies engaged in a form of “jobs blackmail’, threatening to close refineries and waste facilities employing poor and racially marginalised workers if new standards were introduced (Bullard 2000; Kazis and Grossman 1982). At the international scale, environmental justice critiques of ewaste flows have faced pushback from economic development promoters (Wang et al. 2012). Even the Muir-Pinchot debate, a classic in many introductions to environmental studies, can also be read through the “jobs vs the environment” lens (Winston 2015).

The phrase “jobs vs the environment” is typically traced to a series of forestry conflicts in the Northwest Coast of North America, where threats to logging from the legal protection of endangered spotted owls led to the popularisation of the framing of “jobs vs the environment” (Bendix and Liebler 1999; Kirschner 2010). Struggles between environmentalists and loggers continued in debates over clearcutting the old-growth forest in the Clayquot Sound of British Columbia (Hayter 2003; Magnusson and Shaw 2002). Thousands of people travelled to the area to both defend the trees and the loggers’ livelihoods. More broadly, the economic dependency of many communities on resource industries, such as pulp mills, and the environmental movement’s failure to substantively engage with workers’ concerns, has often positioned the environment in opposition to labour (Dunk 1994; Gould 1991; Hayter 2003). More recently, debates over climate change regularly involve questions of the impact of carbon emission controls on workers in the fossil fuel industry in and beyond the north (Nugent 2011; R€athzel and Uzzell 2011; Strambo et al. 2019).

The oppositional framing of jobs and the environment has not gone uncontested. Unions have participated in campaigns to support stronger environmental regulations to reduce workplace risks and protect their communities (Adkin 1998; Obach 2004). International discussions in the 1980s sought to rework global South demands for development through discursively blending concerns with conservation and economic growth. The 1987 United Nations Brundtland Commission popularised the concept of sustainable development, which pushed beyond the conservationist ethos that separated nature and economy, integrating consideration of the importance of global knowledge and technology transfers. Waste recycling, particularly in the global South, is emblematic here: discarded materials are increasing framed as an opportunity for green economic development (and jobs) (e.g. Lawhon et al. 2018; Oelofse et al. 2018). However, substantial critiques have emerged regarding the unsustainability of actually existing sustainable development initiatives that regularly rely on economic growth to expand formal labour market opportunities (Du Pisani 2006; Redclift 2002, 2005).

Is there really a conflict between jobs and the environment? In its simplest form this debate is surely specious, for protection of the planet on which people live is important to all people, workers included (Brecher 2014). More specifically, economists have demonstrated that existing forms of environmental regulations have often had minimal overall impact on jobs, although these studies have largely been undertaken in industrialised economies (e.g. Jaffe et al. 1995; Wagner 2004). The pollution haven hypothesis, which suggests that industries (and thus jobs) relocate to areas with more lax environmental protections, has proven difficult to support (Copeland 2008; Harrison and Eskeland 1997; Kearsley and Riddel 2010). Wider analyses suggest that thus far environmental regulation has not caused significant overall job losses in the broader economy as the green economy tends to be more labour intensive, and “green jobs” replace older jobs in polluting industries (Goodstein 1999).

And yet, stories of unemployment induced by environmental regulations continue to exhibit scale-specific truths that capture political imaginaries and shape political decision-making. Adkin (1998) and Goodstein (1999), for example, examine tensions over energy transitions and their impact on labour in coal and petrochemical sectors. In many rural and Indigenous communities, livelihoods are tied to expanding regimes of resource extraction (Halseth et al. 2014; McCreary 2013; McCreary et al. 2016). With the increasing subsumption of life to capital, people doing social reproductive work—from unpaid mothers in the home to poorly compensated service sector labourers—are increasingly dependent on the recirculation of resource sector wages for their livelihood. This dependence is exacerbated as the increasing scale of resource extraction intensifies environmental impacts that diminish alternative possibilities for living sustainably off the land and makes communities evermore vulnerable to fluctuations in global commodity markets. Together, these circumstances disproportionately burden resource-dependent regions with the weight of environmental impacts and impair their longterm ability to develop a sustainable future, generating deep local opposition to environmentalism as a threat to local livelihoods.

As critics of the cultural politics of extractivism highlight, workers and communities often internalise the rationality of the industries on which they depend. For instance, Pineault (2018) argues that dependence on the fossil fuel industry for survival has contributed to the hegemony of extractivist logics and the inability of North American polities to imagine beyond extractivism. Eaton and Enoch (2018) have found that rural oil-producing communities exhibit a subjective identification with industry, framing responses to environmental issues in terms of industry discourse. The fossil fuel industry has actively cultivated these identifications and the emergence of a form of “extractive populism”, encouraging popular mobilisation in defence of extractive industries presented as synonymous with the common good (Gunster et al. 2020). In addition to traditional advertising campaigns, industry increasingly solicits, coordinates, and amplifies popular political resentment of perceived liberal or left environmental elites (Mayer 2016; Wood 2018). These campaigns have increasing linked working-class subjectivities to the expansion of extractive industries. In this context, conservative politicians have realigned environmental policy in the interests of extractive capital, rationalising it as not only a defence of marginalised resource communities but also the national interest (Carter 2018; Neubauer 2018; Peyton and Franks 2016).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.