Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

And, only a macro level policy like BIG can address macroeconomic instability while ensuring individual benefits that spillover to communities

Hasdell et al., Postdoctoral Research Fellow with the Stanford Basic Income Lab, 2021

[Rebecca, Juliana Bidadanure, Sarah Berger Gonzalez, Healthy Communities and Universal Basic Income: A Conceptual Framework and Evidence Review,” Stanford Basic Income Lab, January 2021, https://basicincome.stanford.edu/uploads/healthy-communities_ubi-paper_final.pdf, accessed May 7, 2023, GDI-TM]

In the absence of a truly universal and unconditional program delivered at scale, policies and programs that share some features with a UBI are used to draw conclusions about the policy’s likely impacts. The outcomes from these UBI-type programs on individual outcomes across contexts has been summarized at length in several systematic reviews of the literature.1 Findings from an umbrella synthesis of existing reviews and reports of the UBI literature are generally positive that UBI-type programs help alleviate poverty and increase economic security through savings, investment and production with minimal impacts on labor market participation. Positive impacts have also been observed for educational attainment and health status (Hasdell 2020). A wider range of social determinants have been pursued by researchers, but evidence is more limited for these outcomes, especially because the geographic scope of the evidence base is narrow. Owusu-Addo, Renzaho and Smith (2018), for example, find evidence for the impact of conditional and unconditional cash transfers on material and psychosocial circumstances, sexual risk behaviors, adolescent empowerment and utilization of health services in sub-Saharan Africa, but they note that cash transfer pathways or mechanisms to improving individual health remain largely unexamined.

There is a shift in some fields towards thinking about health and wellbeing through the framework of healthy communities. But, so far, attention to the community effects of income transfers has been more limited in policy and research debates healthy communities and universal basic income: a conceptual framework and evidence / section 1 surrounding UBI, and no review has focussed exclusively on these impacts. This is a surprising gap given the compelling evidence that a society fares better when income inequalities are reduced (Pickett and Wilkinson 2015)2—a structural outcome that could be reasonably expected from at least some types of UBI. This focus on collective environments and relations has a close affinity to ‘healthy communities’ frameworks and approaches. At its conceptual core, ‘healthier communities’ is the idea that the places where we live, learn, work and play contribute to our ability to become and stay healthy (Robert Wood Johnson (Robert Wood Johnson Foundation 2011). Safe neighborhoods, meaningful work opportunities, access to services and the quality of public education are all factors that contribute to health, or that can drive health inequalities. A ‘healthy communities’ approach can refocus UBI as not merely an individual matter, but as explicitly connected to the fabric where people live out their daily lives, and raises a range of questions about UBI that have received less attention in the empirical literature.3 For example, what new services might open in a community when the people who live there have a secure economic base? What types of jobs are created when individuals have increased bargaining power? What types of governance processes emerge when individuals all receive the same support? These and other questions motivate our interest in looking beyond individual effects to policy goals that can be observed or measured at the community-level.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.