BI solves climate – decreases worker commitment to GDP and stimulates non-consumption activities
Pinto, Universidade do Minho, ‘20
[Jorge, “Environmentalism, Ecologism, and Basic Income”, Basic Income Studies Vol 15.1 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2019-0026accessed 7-11-2023 GDI-FLC]
The compatibility between a BI and ecological sustainability is not, however, obvious (Andersson, 2010). One question immediately comes to mind: if one of the causes of the current ecological crisis is the productivist model of the economy, based on the ever-increasing extraction of natural resources, over-consumption, and the search for permanent economic growth, will not an extra income contribute even further to the promotion of such a system? Questioning the existence of an environmental justification for the BI, Van Parijs presents two possible reasons why the Greens would support the implementation of a BI, concluding that there is a fundamental, albeit indirect, relationship between BI and ecological issues.
The first reason is the fact that economic growth is associated with the unsustainable consumption of nat- ural resources and, as the Greens wish to preserve these resources as much as possible, they will be sceptical regarding a model that depends on permanent economic growth. However, the reduction of economic growth accompanied by an increase in productivity will result in an increase of unemployment, which is why, ac- cording to Van Parijs, there will be popular support for measures that stimulate economic growth and prevent unemployment. The role of the BI would thus be to provide individuals with an economic safety net, regardless of their contribution to the gross domestic product, thus encouraging the performance of activities according to their wishes, in particular the activities outside the formal sphere of the labour market. The author argues however that this reason, on its own, is insufficient to justify the Greens’ support of a BI.
A second reason is then put forward by Van Parijs, and is the fact that many individuals who consider themselves as Green give little importance to the growth of their incomes and to the accumulation of material goods, attributing, on the contrary, great importance to the availability of time for performing the activities they desire. So being “green” and defending a BI share a common cause – the preference for free time – which is why, in order to avoid cognitive dissonance, BI advocates are proportionately more represented in the Green parties. For this reason, Van Parijs concludes, although there is no direct link between BI and ecology, such income would give individuals real freedom, making it more attractive to engage in other non-employment activities, which are typically “far more labour-intensive and less natural-resource-intensive than formal production is” (Van Parijs, 2013, p. 270).