Growth is unsustainable – green tech and innovation can’t solve.
Frenzel 21 [Max (PhD), "Universal Basic Income, Degrowth, and the Future of Work," Medium, 7-27-2021 https://betterhumans.pub/universal-basic-income-degrowth-and-the-future-of-work-9c2f8f94ef78, GDI, TS]
In his book Degrowth, environmental scientist Giorgos Kallis describes the early movement as an “amalgam of research and action — a mixture of researchers, professors, activists and downshifters, who lived as they professed.” From there it has since grown into an active community of academics, with a research conference every two years. In 2014, over 4000 scholars from different fields attended the conference. At the core of degrowth is a “ruthless critique of the dogma of more — the dogma of economic growth.” The Growth Paradigm Our current economy is so deeply rooted in growth that any suggestion otherwise may be seen as crazy. Kallis calls this underlying assumption “‘the growth paradigm’: the idea that perpetual economic growth is natural, necessary and desirable.” But growth needs fuel, and this fuel comprises human and non-human resources. Both these will eventually run low. Our current population growth cannot be sustained forever (and has already started reversing in some countries). And natural resources get depleted. Our current renewable energy technologies have a very low energy return on investment (EROI): lots of energy needs to be invested in getting energy back out. Supporters of “green growth” believe that the EROI of renewables will eventually improve to a point where they can by themselves sustain growth, but, while not impossible, Kallis believes the green growth scenario to be implausible. At first, changing the infrastructure to renewables would come at a huge cost, dampening growth. And eventually, we would need more and more surface area covered with e.g., wind or solar farms. Unless we assume that we can constantly improve technology, sustained growth is physically impossible. The only way to achieve this would be if we discovered a third “Prometheus technology,” a fundamentally new energy technology like fire and steam engines before it. We cannot rule this out (fusion, for example), but relying on it is foolish. As Kallis notes, “by logical necessity economic growth must come to an end, independently of what one measures or how. Constant compound growth of anything quickly runs to infinity.”