Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Green growth and mainstream environmental strategies lock in environmental catastrophe, exploitation, and poverty --- absolute decoupling of emissions from growth is impossible absent a transformation to post growth models

*ev is a k of green growth when pursuing only expansion, answers green growth turns

Langridge, Department of Social and Policy Sciences University of Bath, et al ’23 [Nicholas. “An ecological basic income? Examining the ecological credentials of basic income through a review of selected pilot interventions”, Basic Income Studies 2023 vol 18 (1) De Gruyter Accessed 7-12-2023. GDI-FLC]

Environmentalism encapsulates mainstream responses to the crises which refrain from challenging the political and social consensus. Such responses embrace “means-based” development, the belief that the goal of development is simply to expand the total available means of production and consumption (Patnaik, 2010), and the continued expansion of the global economy through the pursuit of “green growth”. Green growth is a strategy for accruing long-term economic benefits through investment in natural capital, environmental protection and clean-up activities, and an industrial revolution to decarbonise the global economy (Gough, 2017). A primary focus of capitalist economies, green growth forms the foundation of the mainstream environmental movement (Dale et al., 2016) and underlies international policy agreements such as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and the 2015 Paris Agreement (Spash, 2021).

When discussing growth, it is important to distinguish between GDP and material throughput, that is, the natural resources which sustain human activities. Environmentalism argues that we can grow the former while technological innovations reduce the latter.

Green growth relies upon productivism and wage labour. “Green jobs” are a key driver of growth and seen as the means for providing everyone with a stake in a future, green economy (ILO, 2015; Renner et al., 2008; UNDESA, 2012). Compatible welfare systems encourage recipients into the labour market (Standing, 2017) and are funded by growth-reliant taxes (Buchs, 2021).

Green growth is technologically optimistic and reliant on future innovation (Jackson, 2017). Proponents argue that economic activity can be decoupled from environmental pressures through increased efficiencies, resource substitution, and carbon capture and storage technologies. Of the 116 IPCC scenarios for staying within two degrees centigrade of global warming, 101 rely on bio-energy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS) (Hickel, 2020). Advocates argue that growth drives technological breakthroughs as innovation is driven by the pursuit of profit (Kalaniemi et al., 2020). Green growth is seen as both reliant on, and a source of, technological innovation.

A BI aligned with environmentalism would therefore seek to stimulate green growth and economic activity. It would aim to increase labour market participation and encourage innovation, particularly in green technologies. Any accompanying policies would seek to maximise these effects.

3.1.1 The Challenges of Green Growth

Green growth is the subject of two main critiques. First, aggregate economic expansion is an insufficient, and inefficient, method for improving wellbeing. Despite a 65% increase in GDP per capita, the number of people living below $5-a-day has risen by 370 million since 1990 (Hickel, 2017). This is because the benefits of growth are poorly distributed. The 2022 World Inequality Report found that, since the mid-1990s, 38% of new wealth has gone to the richest one percent. The bottom 50% have captured just two percent (Chancel et al., 2022). This means that over a third of “all the labour we’ve rendered, all the resources we’ve extracted, and all the CO2 we’ve emitted … has been done to make rich people richer” (Hickel, 2020, p. 29).

Kallis et al. (2020) argue that economic growth requires inequality and exploitation, both of the poor (traditionally along race and gender lines) and of the environment, in order to generate surplus value. By requiring “certain types of people”, i.e. labourers, growth-based economies also discriminate against “unproductive” citizens who are seen as not contributing to society (Spash, 2021, p. 1128).

Second, further global growth appears incompatible with ecological limits. Absolute decoupling occurs when GDP growth coincides with reductions in emissions or resource use. In other words, it is when the economy grows yet the pressure it exerts on the environment falls absolutely (Parrique et al., 2019). The absolute decoupling of CO2 emissions from economic growth has been observed in certain contexts (Hausfather, 2021). However, it is not occurring at the global level and is not expected to do so any time soon (Anderson & Bows, 2011; Bringezu et al., 2017). Gough (2017) uses the industrial production of bulk materials (cement, steel, etc.) to demonstrate the challenge. Such production accounts for 25% of emissions and is already highly efficient. However, with further economic growth, demand is expected to double over the next four decades meaning that even with further efficiency improvements of 50%, emissions would remain stable. When considering environmental pressures beyond CO2 emissions, such as methane emissions, biodiversity loss, or land use changes, studies find that absolute decoupling is not possible (Haberl et al., 2020; Parrique et al., 2019). Technical solutions, such as recycling, material substitution, or carbon capture and storage, will only make limited contributions and create additional challenges (see Hickel, 2020 for a critique of BECCS).

Several scholars therefore argue that addressing the social and ecological crises cannot be achieved through the pursuit of green growth (Hickel, 2019c; O’Neill et al., 2018; Rao & Min, 2018). Hickel (2019c) found that achieving a good life for all within planetary boundaries requires a 40–50% reduction in the biophysical footprints of rich nations, that is, in the resource use contributing to the crossing of planetary boundaries. This requires a “fundamental reorientation of development theory”, swapping means-based development for the pursuit of sufficiency, and shifting focus away from “the deficiencies of poor countries” and towards the excesses of the rich (p. 31).

3.2 Ecologism

If we employ the precautionary principle, and accept the above critiques, then alternative approaches, which do not involve the pursuit of economic growth, are required to address the social and ecological crises. Dobson (2007, p. 3) uses the term “ecologism” to describe approaches which call for “radical changes in our relationship with the non-human natural world, and in our mode of social and political life”.

3.2.1 From Material Consumption to Human Needs

Human Needs (HN) theories offer an alternative to means-based visions of development which correlate prosperity with material consumption. HN theories recognise that “all individuals, everywhere in the world, at all times present and future, have certain basic needs” which are “objective”, “plural” (i.e., cannot be aggregated), “non-substitutable”, “satiable” and “cross-generational”. “Satisfiers” are the infinite goods, services, relationships, and activities which satisfy HN in a given context or time (Gough, 2017, pp. 42–48). HN theories are people-centred and question the “goals, behaviours, satisfiers, and infrastructure” of mainstream development (Gough, 2017, p. 157).

In their Human Scale Development (HSD) framework, Max-Neef (1991) identified nine fundamental HNs[2] which are met through “systematically related and interdependent” satisfiers. A “synergic satisfier” is one which meets more than one need. Conversely, “inhibitors” or “violators” hinder the satisfaction of other needs (Max-Neef, 1991).

Doyal and Gough’s (1991) Theory of Human Need (THN) identifies “participation in some form of social life without serious systematic limitations” as “our most basic human interest” (Gough, 2017, p. 42). This requires the satisfaction of the “basic needs” of “physical health”, “autonomy of agency” and “critical autonomy” through “culturally specific satisfiers” with several “universal characteristics”.[3] The availability of satisfiers is dependent on “societal preconditions”, including freedom, political participation and the most basic requirements of reproduction and cultural transmission (Gough, 2017, p. 43).

HN theories offer several advantages when considering wellbeing within ecological limits. First, HN theories identify people’s most basic needs, defining a minimum baseline for wellbeing and providing a focal point for production and consumption (Gough, 2017). Second, HN theories provide a normative theory of wellbeing; HNs are universal and applicable across space and time. This requires the preservation of functioning ecosystems so that future generations can satisfy their own needs (Doyal & Gough, 1984). Third, by widening the scope for needs satisfaction beyond material commodities, HN theories allow for non-material satisfiers, such as better relationships and changing values, with lower ecological impacts (Kallis et al., 2020). Finally, HN theories have their roots in sustainability movements (Guillen-Royo, 2018). Max-Neef saw the pursuit of GDP growth as the dehumanisation of development and the subdual of nature. Through HSD he sought to bring human development back into harmony with nature by allowing consideration of the “reasonable use of resources that a person needs to have an acceptable quality of life” (Caria & Domínguez, 2019, para 11). Focusing resources on HN satisfaction, including through non-material satisfiers, has the potential to address the social and ecological crises by reducing unnecessary economic activity and its associated ecological damage.

3.2.2 Post-Development and Post-Growth

HN theories align with the post-development literature. Post-development challenges dominant assumptions, including on growth, and exposes development’s failings and “darker side” (Escobar, 2011; Rodney, 1972/2018). The literature explains how Western prescriptions of development “overlook and marginalise ‘pluriversality’”, rendering other “ontologies and ecologies of knowledge” as “traditional, regressive and non-credible” (Klein & Morreo, 2019, Introduction, para 7). HN theories, in contrast, promote pluriversality through the infinite ways in which satisfiers draw on local knowledge and culture (Gough, 2017).

The challenges of green growth and the critiques of means-based development support the adoption of post-growth perspectives on development. Post-growth perspectives[4] are informed by ecological economics (Martinez-Alier, 2015) and demand the just and equitable downscaling of energy and resource use in order to improve human wellbeing and bring societies into balance with nature (Hickel, 2020; Kallis et al., 2020). Post-growth positions accept the interdependence of the social and ecological crises (Raworth, 2017).

The post-growth literature features several key themes. First, it advocates for aggregate reductions in global material throughput, i.e. the material intensity of the economy, and a respect for ecological limits. Unnecessary overconsumption by the rich would be the primary source of reductions, with an increased focus on sufficiency and the directing of resources towards HN satisfaction (Hickel, 2020). This would likely lead to improvements in quality of life for most people (Hickel, 2019a), especially given that a “substantial amount” of life satisfaction comes from non-material sources, including “social support, generosity, freedom to make life choices and absence of corruption” (O’Neill et al., 2018, p. 93).

Second, post-growth positions prioritise greater equality. This is not only important for social stability (Daly & Farley, 2011) but it also improves wellbeing (Wilkinson & Pickett, 2010) and has ecological benefits, as discussed above. Once basic needs are met, equality contributes more to wellbeing than absolute growth in income (Easterlin, 1995). Post-growth societies would require a more equal distribution of resources in order to facilitate the satisfaction of everyone’s needs without requiring aggregate economic expansion (O’Neill et al., 2018).

Third, social participation and local democracy are important features of post-growth societies (Buchs, 2021; Kallis et al., 2020), as changes need to be endorsed by local citizens: “this can only be achieved through truly democratic and participatory processes” (Buchs, 2021, p. 3). Unimpaired, critical social participation, which embraces community economics and access to the commons, is a fundamental feature of post-growth societies (Gough, 2017).

Fourth, while growth economies involve long labour hours, post-growth societies, free from the need for endlessly increasing production and consumption, would feature reduced hours and the better distribution of work (Devetter & Rousseau, 2011; Jackson, 2017). A 25% reduction in working hours is associated with a 30% reduction in ecological footprint (Knight et al., 2013), as shorter working hours lead to lower average incomes and less unnecessary production and consumption. In addition, increased leisure time is associated with less materially intensive lifestyles (Devetter & Rousseau, 2011) and greater participation in activities in the autonomous sphere, including care, volunteering, and community and cultural activities (Gorz, 1999; Van Parijs, 2010). Such activities can generate “a greater sense of wellbeing and fulfilment” than the “time-poor, materialistic, supermarket economy in which much of our lives is spent” (Jackson, 2017, p. 149) and are also thought to be have a lower ecological impact (Boulanger, 2010).

Fifth, post-growth societies prioritise different values to growth-based economies. Kallis et al. (2020, p. 23) argue that the centrality of markets and consumption under capitalism has created individuals that are detached from community and the natural world and are “vulnerable to promises of pleasure, identity, and meaning through consumption”. Responsible citizens are seen as “good consumer[s], buying and consuming as much and as fast as possible” (Spash, 2021, p. 1129). In addition, the view of humans as separate to, and above, nature justifies its exploitation (Hickel, 2020). Post-growth societies would instead be “guided by values of community wellbeing rather than competition and growth” (Kallis et al., 2020, p. 45) and view of society as embedded within nature, rather than separate from it (Moore, 2015). This requires change at the individual, communal, and political levels as focusing on individuals alone “underestimate[s] the power of socio-cultural systems” (Kallis et al., 2020, p. 20).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.