Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

No decoupling – empirics, speed, and incentives

Pinto, Universidade do Minho, ‘20

[Jorge, “Environmentalism, Ecologism, and Basic Income”, Basic Income Studies Vol 15.1 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2019-0026accessed 7-11-2023 GDI-FLC]

There are many reasons ecologists reject an economy based on permanent growth, but chief among them is the fact that the decoupling between economic growth and the ecological impacts is not observed. In fact, a recent report observed that there [is] no empirical evidence supporting the existence of a decoupling of economic growth from en- vironmental pressures on anywhere near the scale needed to deal with environmental breakdown, but also, and perhaps more importantly, such decoupling appears unlikely to happen in the future (Parrique et al., 2019, p. 3; Cf. Hickel & Kallis, 2019).

How would a BI be part of an environmental or ecological approach to economy? First, in an environmental approach, a BI could be introduced to achieve a positive environmental impact, without this implying any structural change to the economic model – and, taken to the extreme, even opposing such structural changes. This model of BI could be introduced as part of the current economic model and, as such, the search for an alternative to a growth-dependent economy would not be a priority. The environmentalist BI could integrate a package of green growth measures in which economic growth is seen as important, if not essential, to ensure environmental sustainability.

The environmental economist will look primarily to Pigovian taxes, perhaps alongside regulations and tax incentives and research, and a dividend is a partial BI that could be one use of the revenue. By internalising the environmental costs of the economy, this environmental model would be interested in promoting sustainability but it weakens the case for a BI, because it is only one use of the revenue (more on this below).

Since environmentalism does not require changes to the levels of production and consumption, and since the separation between growth and resource consumption (total or relative4 decoupling) has not yet been observed (Jackson, 2017; Parrique et al., 2019), the environmental would likely be technologically optimistic. According to this view, the current patterns of production and consumption, even if environmentally unsustainable, can be maintained because new technological solutions that will correct and compensate for those impacts will eventually be developed. This is also the position advocated by some environmentalists, such as the 19 scien- tists who signed the “Ecomodernist Manifesto” arguing that there is no need for more radical changes to the economic model or limits in terms of consumption; what is required are technological solutions that will allow the decoupling of human development from environmental impacts (Asafu-Adjaye et al., 2015).5 This type of proposal is sometimes associated with the need to have market incentives in order to promote green innovation (Friedman, 2008).

It is not surprising that ecologists look to this approach reluctantly. Even if technological solutions to com- pensate for the environmental impact of human activities are created and the separation between economic growth and consumption is achieved, should this happen after the loss of biodiversity (including the extinc- tion of animals and plants) or after passing the planetary boundaries beyond the point of no return – that is, the critical point after which the consequences for the planet are unpredictable – then it may be too late. Instead of taking a defeatist attitude toward the possibility of changing the economic system, advocates of ecologism will, in a proactive way, try to promote these changes, defending a model of prosperity that does not depend on economic growth (Jackson, 2017). For the sake of clarity, it is this vision of ecologism I subscribe to.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.