Squo caregiving expectations both increase stress and destroy women’s careers
Hess et al, COO at the Institute for Women’s Policy Research, 20
[Cynthia, “Providing Unpaid Household and Care Work in the United States: Uncovering Inequality”, Institute for Women’s Policy Research, January 2020, https://iwpr.org/providing-unpaid-household-and-care-work-in-the-united-states-uncovering-inequality/ 7/12/23 GDI- SC]
Spending time on care for elders or children can be satisfying and a source of considerable happiness. Connelly and Kimmel (2014) find, however, that while parents often enjoy spending time caring for their children, fathers are much more likely to enjoy such time than mothers. This is possibly because for fathers the time spent on unpaid care is more likely to represent a positive choice and less likely to have come at the cost of dialing back career advancement. At the same time, fathers report growing work-family conflict, which may be partly a result of lower social acceptance in the sphere of employment for their role as care providers (Connolly and Kimmel 2014). While both women and men may want to provide more care for their children or for other family members, without adequate resources and external supports their provision of this care can lead to significant stress.
Work-family conflict can reduce mental and physical well-being; these effects are particularly strong in relation to elder care. Elder care needs are increasing rapidly (Mather, Jacobsen, and Pollard 2015) and may arise more suddenly and intensively than child care needs, making them harder to prepare for (Reinhard et al. 2011) and more stressful than other caregiving demands (Perrig-Chiello and Hutchinson 2010). Combining employment with these caregiving responsibilities—particularly for women—leads to significantly higher levels of stress than those experienced by non-caregiving peers (MetLife 2011). A survey of more than 1,200 unpaid caregivers in the United States who care for an adult found that 22 percent feel their own health has declined as a result of their caregiving, physically or emotionally (or both). Nineteen percent reported experiencing a high level of physical strain as a result of their caregiving, and 38 percent said they find the work stressful. Those in more difficult care situations—such as those caring for someone with a mental health issue or residing with the care recipient—experienced higher levels of emotional strain (National Alliance for Caregiving and AARP 2015). This strain may especially affect women of color, who have higher rates of both paid (Hess and Hegewisch 2019) and unpaid caregiving (National Alliance for Caregiving and AARP 2015).
Jobs that provide little flexibility in work hours and limited control over one’s work schedule and location add to the stress for workers with caregiving responsibilities. As a result, some researchers suggest that many employees could benefit from organizational interventions to train supervisors to be more supportive and to give workers more schedule control and ability to work from home (Kossek et al. 2019; Moen et al. 2016). One study that tested the effects of such an intervention for elder care workers found that paid care workers, especially those with care responsibilities at home, may experience reduced stress and psychological distress as a result of interventions to increase social support for work and non-work roles, and job control (Kossek et al. 2019).
Reducing time in the paid workforce may also help alleviate this stress, particularly for dualcareer couples whose financial situation can weather the decrease in income. As noted, however, it can also have implications for women’s career trajectories and advancement. One study found that once caregivers reduce their time in the paid labor force, they are unlikely to return to their previous levels even after their caregiving responsibilities end (Wakabayashi and Donato 2005).
The high levels of time demands that come with caring for an adult or for children can result in caregivers’ limiting their participation not only in the paid workforce but in other activities as well. One study that analyzed when and why women decide to run for elected office, for example, found that many women delay running because of their child care responsibilities (Baer and Hartmann 2014). Another study that examined time spent in work and leisure found that among all women and men aged 15 and older, a “leisure gap” exists: while women and men spend about equal amounts of time on work (with men spending more on paid work and women more on household and child care), men spend, on average, approximately six hours more per week (49 minutes per day) doing leisure activities[.], such as playing sports, watching TV, socializing, and playing games (U.S. Department of Labor 2019b)