Unpaid caregiving furthers gender wage gaps and crushes Social Security money
Hess et al, COO at the Institute for Women’s Policy Research, 20
[Cynthia, “Providing Unpaid Household and Care Work in the United States: Uncovering Inequality”, Institute for Women’s Policy Research, January 2020, https://iwpr.org/providing-unpaid-household-and-care-work-in-the-united-states-uncovering-inequality/ 7/12/23 GDI- SC]
The disproportionate share of unpaid household and care work that women perform has a range of costs for them, including employment and economic costs. Caregiving takes time, and when caregiving duties become extensive, many caregivers cut back time in paid work (Lilly, Laporte, and Coyte 2007), in part because the high cost of paid care makes it unaffordable for many families (Hess et al. 2015). Most caregivers who reduce their hours at work or step out of the paid labor force altogether are women (U.S. Department of Labor 2018b), since for many families it makes economic sense for the woman to be the one to reduce her time in the paid workforce, given women’s lower average earnings. While some women may want to reduce their hours at paid work to spend more time with children or other family members who need care, for others the “choice” to not participate in paid work is constrained by the impossibility of meeting the demands of both their paid employment and their family’s needs (Hegewisch and Lacarte 2019). A lack of family-friendly work policies in many workplaces, such as paid family and medical leave and paid sick days that would allow one time off from work to care for a sick child without penalty, exacerbates the challenges many workers face in meeting both family care and work demands, and results in lower rates of labor force participation for women in the United States compared with other high-income countries (Blau and Kahn 2013).
The decision to reduce time at paid work owing to the demands of unpaid work (or to continue full-time employment without putting in long hours at paid work) has both short- and long-term economic consequences for women. As Cha notes (2010), reducing time in the paid workforce can lead to fewer opportunities for advancement, since “making it to the top” in managerial and professional occupations often requires working long hours, and management may interpret a worker’s “unwillingness” to work these hours as a sign of lack of dedication to their job. These more limited opportunities for advancement can contribute to the gender gap in earnings women face; although the gap exists at younger ages, it increases when women and men reach their early thirties (Hegewisch et al. 2015), a time when many are raising young children. While men may also face consequences at work if they request time to provide care, the data show that more women reduce time in the paid workforce. As a result, many men continue to receive promotions in the earlier years of their career, while women’s upward mobility stalls (Benard, Correll, and Paik 2007; Benard and Correll 2010; King 2008).
The decline in the gender earnings ratio during child-bearing years suggests that the gender wage gap over a lifetime is much larger than in any one year. When the earnings for all women and men who worked in at least one year in the previous 15 years are taken into account, Rose and Hartmann (2018) found a gender earnings ratio of only 49 percent, a much larger wage gap (51 percent) than the 20 percent gap usually reported. Forty-three percent of women workers during this time had at least one year with no earnings, more than twice the rate of men. Both women and men suffered earnings losses for time out of the paid labor force; for women and men who took just one year off from work between 2001 and 2015, their earnings in the years with work were 39 percent lower than the earnings for those who worked continuously for all 15 years (Rose and Hartmann 2018). Losses for those who take four or more years out of the paid workforce in this 15-year period are particularly steep for women (whose earnings are 65 percent lower than those of women who worked continuously; men’s earnings are 57 percent lower than for those who did not take time out of the paid workforce). As noted, women are more likely to take time out of the paid workforce for reasons related to care. Lower lifetime earnings due to time out of the workforce leads to a lower Social Security benefit in retirement (Social Security Administration 2019), making it more difficult at older ages for women (and men) to make ends meet.
While women’s lower earnings compared with men’s are not due solely to the unequal distribution of unpaid household and care work, this work plays an important role. IWPR analysis of ATUS data finds that a 1 percent increase in time spent on unpaid work is associated with a 0.062 percent decrease in women’s weekly earnings when controlling for age, education, race/ethnicity, marital status, place of birth, and family income. Unpaid work has no effect on men’s earnings when controlling for the same characteristics (Appendix Table 2).
The negative association of unpaid work on women’s earnings is largest for women in higherincome families (those with annual incomes above $60,000; Appendix Table 2). This does not mean, however, that the impact in less well-off households is less significant. As noted, the gender wage gaps in lower-income households are smaller than in higher-income ones partly because lower-income households cannot afford to cut back hours of paid work. Any negative impact on women’s earnings makes it more difficult for these households to build savings and prepare for eventual retirement. Time conflicts between the need to provide care and the need to make ends meet may also reduce the quality of care that many low-income families are able to provide.