BIG solves housing instability – cuts bureaucratic nightmare of rent assistance programs
Bogle et al, principal research associate at MHCPC, 2022
[Mary, “Guaranteed Income as a Mechanism for Promoting Housing Stability”, Urban Institute, December 30, https://www.urban.org/research/publication/guaranteed-income-mechanism-promoting-housing-stability, 7-11-2023 GDI- SPB]
Some in the housing advocacy and research fields argue that, given the often slow pace and high costs of affordable housing development, allocating a greater balance of limited resources to direct cash subsidies for rent-burdened households could be a far more efficient and cost-effective means of getting housing relief to families experiencing the deleterious effects of ongoing rent burden. As one pilot leader said, “I think [approaching] housing affordability with rent assistance programs, [such as HCVs and emergency rental assistance], has been really helpful. But I think if you talk to families about the rent assistance program, it is a bureaucratic nightmare and a hardship.” The argument goes that getting a direct payment to a cost-burdened family addresses their cost differences right now, rather than leaving them languishing on waiting lists, funneling their payments to landlords, or giving them “vouchers to nowhere.” Roger Valdez, director of the Center for Housing Economics and a research fellow at the Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity, a leading proponent of cash as a housing solution, writes, Direct cash payments mean fewer operating costs, financing costs, and construction costs assumed by funding agencies and taxpayers. Cash payments for housing would mean letting the private sector take on more of the risk and costs but still help families who need housing without having to buy land and build. A finely tuned cash-based program could also allow families to set aside money in a savings account if their income increases over time, allowing them to capture some of the subsidy for a future home purchase or for college expenses. Now these payments and other costs savings would mean the cadre of attorneys, consultants, and tax credit syndicates would lose money for their own operations. But is that a priority? Instead a cash benefit system could be part of an overall improvement in efficiency and empower families with more cash, cash that could, with support, mean getting them out of poverty in the long term. We’ve forgotten that subsidized housing, in most cases, ought to be about ending the cycle of poverty, not perpetuating an expensive unit-building, bureaucratic machine.34