Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

BIG stabilizes precarious housing situations, especially for those denied access to rental assistance

Bogle et al, principal research associate at MHCPC, 2022

[Mary, “Guaranteed Income as a Mechanism for Promoting Housing Stability”, Urban Institute, December 30, https://www.urban.org/research/publication/guaranteed-income-mechanism-promoting-housing-stability, 7-11-2023 GDI- SPB] 

Many housing subsidy programs are designed to prevent worst-case housing scenarios, such as homelessness, especially for populations whose needs are deepest, like people with mental illness and few resources. However, as noted above, a substantial portion of first-time homeless are people experiencing short-term financial shocks due to often hard-to-predict financial setbacks like job loss, divorce, or health crises (Ellen and O'Flaherty 2010). Given the many barriers to access inherent in categorical housing policies, cash infusion may be the most efficient mechanism for stabilizing households who struggle to pay the rent on only a transitory or intermittent basis but who cannot easily access standard housing supports because of eligibility gaps and long waiting lists. In turn, this could relieve stress on emergency solutions like homeless shelters and transitional housing. As noted by İmrohoroğlu and Zhao (2021), “Economic theory [could] help us design mechanisms that will reduce the flow to homelessness for the fraction of the population who become homeless due to bad shocks. If such polices could be useful, then the burden on the system to deal with the rest of the homeless population would be more manageable.” A look at data emerging from research on flexible rent subsidies provides a glimpse into how cash might be the most finely tuned instrument for helping families who are currently housed but remain one shock away from homelessness. A flexible subsidy allows renters to decide how much of the subsidy to spend each month, up to their total rent. This flexibility can be particularly valuable for workers whose earnings fluctuate, such as seasonal workers and those in the gig economy, who have been especially hard hit this past year.22 Typically, local housing entities send flexible rent subsidies directly to landlords. Among the most rigorously studied of these programs is Project Independence in Alameda County, California. Project Independence is a shallow rent subsidy program with services coordination support for people with very low incomes living with HIV or AIDS. On average, participants were paying 68 percent of their monthly income on rent before receiving the subsidy, and 42 percent of their monthly income on rent with the subsidy. Although most Project Independence participants remained at least moderately rent-burdened, the subsidy was sufficient to keep them stably housed. Two years from the baseline survey, 96 percent of Project Independence participants were still in rental housing, versus 10 percent of the comparison group. Over the five-year study period, the average time in rental housing for Project Independence participants was 3.9 years versus one year for the comparison group. Thus, although the shallow subsidy left most participants moderately rent-burdened, it appeared to be sufficient for keeping them stably housed. However, the authors noted that unobserved differences between the treatment and control groups, such as prior rental history, may help explain the stark differences in housing stability (Cunningham and Leopold 2014).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.