Universality is key to resolve stigma of support programs and ensure long-term viability of the program – research proves
Clarke, lecturer in sociology at the University of New South Wales, 2022
[Andrew, “Can a basic income help address homelessness? A Titmussian Perspective”, Journal of Sociology, November 15, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/14407833221135986 7-13-2023 GDI-SPB]
Beyond addressing the structural drivers of homelessness, I argue that a BI can also help increase support for, and reduce the stigma and blame arising from, responses to homelessness generally. One way a BI will do this is by replacing targeted measures with a universal one that benefits, and thus will enjoy the support of, a broader political constituency. As colleagues and I have argued elsewhere, governments – and by extension publics – tend to support actions to address homelessness when these actions produce benefits for the broader community (Parsell et al., 2020). This can be seen in the willingness of even conservative governments to invest in expensive housing first programs because these programs are shown to produce overall savings to taxpayers (Culhane, 2008; Parsell et al., 2017). It can also be seen in the large-scale investment in accommodating the homeless during the Covid-19 pandemic because this group was identified as a potential source of virus transmission and thus a threat to public health (Parsell et al, 2020). Given a BI would be paid to everyone on an individual basis, more people would have a stake in its continuation, unlike the targeted measures that support people experiencing or at risk of homelessness alone. A BI is also less likely to attract the stigma that is attached to existing targeted measures for addressing homelessness. As noted above, research on BI-like measures that involve broad-based payments show that these are perceived as more ‘normal’ by publics than targeted measures, because they do not mark out their recipients as uniquely needy or deficient (Calnitsky, 2016). A BI would thus constitute an important break with prevailing liberal responses to homelessness, which (a) are highly targeted and restricted to minimise the possibility of dependence and market disengagement (Evans et al., 2021); and (b) treat homelessness as the product of individual pathologies or proclivities, and thus attract substantial stigma (Farrugia & Gerrard, 2016; Mitchell, 2011; Willse, 2015). In this way, a BI is superior to existing measures used to address the income side of the housing affordability problem in liberal welfare regimes, such as rental subsidies and vouchers (see also Kerman, 2021, pp. 6–7 on this point). These measures are typically highly targeted (through means tests and assessment of individual needs/pathologies) Clarke 13 and thus mark out their recipients as problem individuals, leading to stigmatisation and discriminatory treatment. Indeed, research shows that users of housing vouchers, such as the Section 8 housing voucher in the United States, experience significant stigma and discrimination from private landlords (Desmond, 2016). Voucher holders are perceived as ‘riskier’ tenants and thus struggle to compete with other renters in tight rental markets, despite having the same capacity to pay. A BI is also superior to simply increasing existing income support payments (although this would certainly be a positive development). For, such a move does little to combat the divisions and resultant stigma produced by these measures and which Bauman (2005) argues are a core reason why they have deteriorated to such an extent in the first place.