Degrowth possible through slow reform – fast transition causes economic disaster and collapse
Frenzel 21 [Max (PhD), "Universal Basic Income, Degrowth, and the Future of Work," Medium, 7-27-2021 https://betterhumans.pub/universal-basic-income-degrowth-and-the-future-of-work-9c2f8f94ef78, GDI, TS]
“Degrowth,” writes Kallis, “refers to a trajectory where the ’throughput’ (energy, materials and waste flows) of an economy decrease while welfare, or well-being improves.” Crucially, this is not the same as negative growth or recession. The focus is on reducing throughput, the use of resources, while improving living conditions. Whether output and GDP decrease in the process is a different but rather irrelevant matter. “The problem is not only that the economy cannot or should not grow. Our very ideas of what an economy is are wrong.” We are simply measuring the wrong thing. The problem is, we have been measuring growth in this way for a long time and built a system that relies on the continuation of this kind of growth. Kallis admits that directly switching our current economy to the degrowth mindset would lead to economic disaster and collapse. Instead, we need small steps to rebuild a new economy from the ground up. The push for this comes from two directions. From the outside, as a criticism of economic thinking itself, but also from inside economics, considering the risk and cost of growth, which can outweigh the benefits. The agenda of the degrowth research program is to find out how and under what conditions such a transition can happen without disaster. Even if such conditions can be found, everyone involved knows that achieving political change will still be difficult. “Unlike ecological laws, however, political systems can change. It was hard to end slavery, but it was not impossible. It is impossible, though, to change the law of entropy.” Overall, the degrowth proposition looks positive, according to Kallis: “A transformation of society with a concomitant reduction in economic activity and throughput is not only necessary, and desirable, but also possible.” If we achieve a transition to degrowth, we might find ourselves once again in a society that values time off as one of its highest virtues. French economics professor Serge Latouche, one founder of the degrowth movement, has a concept called the “eight Rs” of degrowth. One of the Rs he describes as “reevaluating, that is, valuing the ‘pleasure of leisure,’ for example, or the ‘ethos of play’ instead of material possessions.” Similarly, Ph.D. researcher Aaron Vansintjan at Birbeck, University of London, imagines a society after degrowth with, among other things, “surpluses expended in popular feasts, philosophy or leisure, instead of invested for more growth; and conviviality and caring for one another, and for non-human living beings.” It sounds a lot like the positive aspects of ancient Rome or Greece, bringing us full circle to a culture of noble leisure that Aristotle advocated for. Previous civilizations have flourished under this kind of model, and potentially we can do so once again.