Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

BI aids in degrowth – it provides a safety net that solves recession impacts while shaping movements towards resource consumption decline

Pinto, Universidade do Minho, ‘20

[Jorge, “Environmentalism, Ecologism, and Basic Income”, Basic Income Studies Vol 15.1 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2019-0026accessed 7-11-2023 GDI-FLC]

It is not surprising that ecologists look to this approach reluctantly. Even if technological solutions to com- pensate for the environmental impact of human activities are created and the separation between economic growth and consumption is achieved, should this happen after the loss of biodiversity (including the extinc- tion of animals and plants) or after passing the planetary boundaries beyond the point of no return – that is, the critical point after which the consequences for the planet are unpredictable – then it may be too late. Instead of taking a defeatist attitude toward the possibility of changing the economic system, advocates of ecologism will, in a proactive way, try to promote these changes, defending a model of prosperity that does not depend on economic growth (Jackson, 2017). For the sake of clarity, it is this vision of ecologism I subscribe to.

The ecological BI would then be designed in such a way as to defy the consumerist and productivist society, in which economic growth is seen as essential both for generating jobs and for supporting the Social State (Dobson, 2007). An ecological BI, although not technophobic, would be sceptical about the role that techno- logical solutions alone can play. In this way, ecologists would argue in favour of the reduction of unnecessary consumption, especially in the richest countries, where it is, on average, higher (WWF, 2016; Cf. Victor, 2019). Furthermore, technological developments could allow this BI model to contribute to the definition of a new way of life, independent of the economic growth paradigm.

Contrary to the environmental scenario, an ecological BI could be part of a non-growth or even a degrowth policy. It should be clarified that degrowth should not be understood as an uncontrolled economic recession that would have disastrous social (and ecological) consequences. On the contrary, a policy of sustainable de- growth would imply a smooth transition “through a range of social, environmental, and economic policies and institutions, orchestrated to guarantee that while production and consumption decline, human welfare improves and is more equally distributed” (Kallis, 2018, p. 12; cf. Latouche & Macey, 2009; Victor, 2019).

According to D’Alisa, Demaria, and Kallis (2014), authors of a dictionary of degrowth, this concept is based on three main reasons to oppose policies based on economic growth: 1) growth is unfair and unequal in terms of the distribution of benefits, 2) growth is ecologically unsustainable, and 3) growth will never be enough. They add that growth is likely to have both internal and external limits, such as limits on the creation of demand and limits on the access to natural resources. For these reasons, they argue, a degrowth society would be different, from energy usage to interpersonal relations, including different distributions of work, paid or unpaid, favouring the latter.

The debate between green growth and degrowth advocates has been extremely rich in the past couple of years. Robert Pollin, a green growth critic of degrowth, points out that even a 10 % global contraction of Gross World Product over twenty years – a contraction four times larger than that of 2007–2009 – would reduce emis- sions by only 10 %. As such, the bulk of emissions reductions must come from other policies beyond contracting GDP. Furthermore, Pollin argues, a degrowth policy resulting in mass unemployment has little chance of being politically acceptable (Pollin, 2015).

And it is precisely at this level that a BI might enter an ecological strategy, as it arises here as a necessary measure to deal with the unemployment and impoverishment that would otherwise accompany a large reces- sion, in a way that is not just palliative, but positively an improvement in everyone’s lives. As mentioned in the previous section, this is not, in itself, a “green” reason to support a BI. Thus, from an ecological perspective, this BI would serve not only to avoid popular opposition to measures that reduce economic growth, but as well to foster a reduction of labour hours, promoting better distribution of available jobs. It would as well reduce the pressure for individuals to accept jobs that they might not be interested in and that have a negative ecological impact. Finally, ecologists would see a BI fitting their strategy of promotion of the autonomous sphere and promotion of more frugal ways of living.

This ecological BI would support post-productivism and degrowth policies, contributing to rethinking of the role of paid employment in society. However, as noted in Section 2, measures that result in increased un- employment will most likely have popular opposition. The degrowth advocates are aware of this fact, which is why they are proposing a series of measures that, together with a BI, can facilitate and promote the transition from a society of employment to a society of work. These measures include job-sharing, substantial reduction in the number of working hours, the introduction of complementary currencies, or even a maximum income (Howard, Pinto, & Schachtschneider, 2019).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.