Current food production and consumption contributes to environmental damages – only a BIG stimulates pro-environment food practices through expanded resources for farmers and consumers
Macneill 19 (Tim - Doctor of Philosophy, Senior Teaching Professor at Ontario Tech University. “Universal Basic Income and the Natural Environment: Theory and Policy.” Basic Income Studies, 14(1), June 2019, https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2018-0026, Accessed 7.16.23 gdi-flc]
Irrespective of its impact on health, food production and consumption have direct environmental impacts that could be augmented via a BIG. The food system is one of the largest contributors to greenhouse gas emissions, deforestation, desertification, eutrophication, and biodiversity loss (Goggins & Rau, 2016). These impacts relate to an increased reliance on environmentally damaging international transport, refrigeration, and industrial petro-chemical-based production techniques (Clark & Tilman, 2017). Although there are controversies regarding the accounting of sectoral impacts (Jones et al., 2016), some analyses have shown that the livestock industry alone may have the largest ecological impact of any human sector (Herrero et al., 2013). Accordingly, solutions to environmental crises often include the support of local production, fairly traded goods, sustainable farming practices, and reduced meat consumption (Goggins & Rau, 2016). Many experts argued that a BIG could stimulate such pro-environment food practices by increasing the money and time resources of individuals.
Some have also claimed that environmentally sustainable production could be directly stimulated by providing a basic income for farmers. Aric McBay (2018), of the National Farmers Union of Ontario (NFUO), proposes a BIG pilot that is specifically allocated to farmers in order to study this relationship. Urgency the NFUO has for this pilot proposal is driven by the increasing challenges facing the population of farmers. These include the rising price of farmland which deters young people from farming, an aging farm population with no succession plans, extreme weather conditions, and corporate control of the food system.
McBay argues that farmers who may want to market high-quality, sustainably-produced foods are often compelled to integrate into the more environmentally damaging agro-industrial system to survive. Ivanova (2018) similarly highlights the increasing difficultly that farmers face sustaining livable incomes in Canada, and Dixon, Gibbon, Gulliver, and Hall (2001) have shown that this is a global phenomenon. McBay and the NFUO argue that a basic income would provide income that farmers can invest in sustainable production and allow them to avoid environmentally harmful practices that they may be compelled to follow due to the compulsion to avoid poverty. Accordingly, an increased supply of sustainably produced foods may reduce prices of these goods to consumers, making environmentally sustainable food consumption more affordable. The French Movement for Basic Income has made a similar call for BI as an integral part of supporting ecologically sustainable local food production (MFRB, 2018).