Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Biased agency administrators deny access to welfare programs in the status quo. BIG overcomes mistrust and solves circumvention

Bogle et al, principal research associate at MHCPC, 2022

[Mary, “Guaranteed Income as a Mechanism for Promoting Housing Stability”, Urban Institute, December 30, https://www.urban.org/research/publication/guaranteed-income-mechanism-promoting-housing-stability, 7-11-2023 GDI- SPB] 

Guaranteed income, which aims to fill safety net gaps in critical needs like affordable housing, can help challenge the tendency of the American polity and its representatives to mistrust people who use the safety net, especially people who are heavily stigmatized by living in substandard housing or who have experienced homelessness. This mistrust lies at the heart of a commonly held belief that some people are more deserving of assistance than others, in which deservingness is measured by perceptions of how responsible the recipients are and how willing they are to work (Steinberger 2020). This mistrust does not affect just housing safety net users. It is baked into the workings of most policies and institutions meant to serve low-income people. For example, in one study, researchers observed that staff in benefits-administering agencies expressed much unease with “giving people money” if they felt those people did not deserve those funds. Not only that, administrators can act on this unease by withholding cash transfers from those eligible to receive them (Steinberger 2020). A recent World Bank and Stanford University study, “Cash Transfers and Temptation Goods,” corroborates behavioral economics research that finds when money is given for a specific purpose, such as housing, people and organizations tend to use it for that purpose, even when no one is monitoring them (Evans and Popova 2017). In addition, other studies show that people with low incomes are not inclined to consume temptation goods with extra cash any more than people with higher incomes (Evans and Popova 2017). A pilot leader from Austin questioned the equity of common societal expectations when he said, “[Should] we monitor or audit what [participants in the pilot] are spending the money on? I think that we have some soul searching to do around that.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.