Prabhakar, senior lecturer in personal finance, 22
[Rajiv Prabhakar, “Are Temporary or Permanent Income Payments Better Placed to Boost Demand during Covid-19?,” Basic Income Studies 17(1) p. 15-27 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2020-0022 Gonzaga – Ebsco accessed 7-11-2023 GDI–AL]
Evidence to date on both vouchers and emergency payments suggest that these policies only have a modest role in raising demand. One might still support a universal basic income as a way of guaranteeing social protection or social justice. However, the case for income payments as a demand stimulus might be stronger if these were permanent, as with a universal basic income, rather than temporary. One reason for this is that a universal basic income might perform as an automatic stabilizer to smooth consumption over the economic cycle. Much of the existing literature on automatic stabilizers does not focus specifically on a universal basic income but rather on other taxes or benefits (Maravalle & Rawdanowicz, 2020; Sahm, 2019). But there may be a case for extending automatic stabilisers to cover policies such as a universal basic income. Moffitt and Ziliak (2020) say that there is a patchwork of policies providing social assistance in the US. The most important of these are unemployment insurance (which varies by state) and the Federal Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) or ‘food stamps’. Moffitt and Ziliak (2020) propose extra Federal cash for low-income families with young children as a way to cut income volatility during economic shocks. These researchers do not consider the role of a universal basic income, but this might nevertheless act as an automatic stabilizer to smooth demand over the economic cycle. Sahm (2019) is more explicit about the role of direct stimulus payments as an automatic stabiliser. Her proposal was shaped before the onset of Covid-19 and drew on research on the effects of stimulus payments around the time of the global financial crisis of 2008–2009. Based on her analysis of stimulus payments made after the global financial crisis of 2009–09, she calls for: ‘direct payments to individuals as an automatic stabilizer. The lump-sum annual payments would be made to individuals, regardless of their income level, when the national unemployment rate rises by at least 0.50% points’ (Sahm, 2019, 67). Sahm’s idea is not a universal basic income as the trigger for the payments is the unemployment rate. But this proposal highlights the ways that the discussion of automatic stabilizers could extend to cover income payments besides policies such as unemployment benefit. A case for permanent over temporary payments need not be tied only to an argument about automatic stabilizers. Other economic traditions also provide an argument for permanent over temporary payments. Friedman’s Permanent Income Hypothesis suggests that people base their consumer spending upon a notion of permanent income that stretches across their lifetime. Theory and empirical tests of the Permanent Income Hypothesis suggest that a change in permanent income will have a bigger effect on consumer spending than a change in temporary income (Aguiar & Hurst, 2008; Friedman, 1957; Lugilde, Bande, & Riveiro, 2019; Meghir, 2004). A universal basic income would add to a permanent income and so could be expected to have a bigger impact than temporary payments.