UBI + reframes societal treatment of labor and its racialized marginalization
The Undercommons, 2017
[The Undercommons is a freedom school in Los Angeles that was started at UCLA. It works to provide oppressed peoples' social movements with the resources housed at universities, “No Racial Justice Without Basic Income” Boston Review May 3, 2017 accessed 6.23.23 GDI-TM]
More radical challenges to racial capitalism are possible. UBI+, by guaranteeing everyone an income sufficient to live on, reframes the way society treats labor and provides security to its citizens. For example, this kind of guarantee recognizes that the labor of raising children and caring for the elderly—work done disproportionately by women—is valued as work. Currently much of this work is uncompensated, and as a result we economically and socially marginalize those who do it. In a capitalist system where economic value and overall value are often conflated, this reinforces the idea that caregiving is not an important contribution to society and penalizes people who try to do this work alongside paid work (e.g., child-unfriendly work policies, expensive child care, lack of clear leave policies for caring for children or elders). UBI- would provide a guaranteed income but eliminate programs that respond to these specific concerns, such as those provided by Social Security that target the needs of elderly and disabled people. This would effectively offer security with one hand while taking it with the other.