Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Turn - UBI trades off better systems and exacerbates marginalization

Iyahen et al , UN Women’s Headquarters, 21 [ Isiuwa, “Universal Basic Income as a means of Gender-Responsive Social Protection”, Joint SGD Fund, 9/22/2021, access info https://www.jointsdgfund.org/article/universal-basic-income-means-gender-responsive-social-protection, date accessed 7/13/2023, GDI-AL]

Some caution however that if a UBI is considered only as a minimal safety net, it could be used to justify the roll back of state responsibility and funding of social security systems that provide comparatively higher levels of protection including care services, housing, education and health care.

Other limitations of introducing a UBI that were considered were:

In a climate of fiscal tightening and austerity, is there the fiscal space in the Caribbean to implement a UBI?

A flat rate UBI still may not fully meet the needs of specific groups, e.g. single parents and people living with disabilities as there are higher costs for care needs or not having shared household income, and therefore may require paid work to complement.

There cannot be a one-sized approach as some territories already have social welfare polices – universal access to education, subsidised childcare services, school meals programmes.

UBI may be treated as a “housewives wage”, encouraging women to remain at home and continue doing unpaid care work while male breadwinners bring in additional income.

A UBI would not reduce poverty and inequality if paid only at a low level.

A UBI does not ensure decent work and may be used as excuse by employers to not pay living wage or provide benefits, which may lead to higher rates of informal work.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.