UBI doesn’t solve climate – strengthens role of money, fails to change social relations, doesn’t address fossil fuels, AND causes public service cuts
Hiilamo, Professor of Social Policy University of Helsinki, ’23 [Heikki “What Is Participation Income and How Can It Help Communities Fight Climate Change?” World Economic Forum, 24 Mar. 2023, www.weforum.org/agenda/2023/03/what-is-participation-income-and-how-can-it-help-communities-fight-climate-change/. Accessed 12 July 2023. GDI-FLC]
There is fledgling research on new models of a welfare state which is not built on productivity and economic growth, but upon an architecture of sustainable wellbeing and care. UBI is the best known alternative to traditional welfare states. But it fails to meet the challenge for building a sustainable and just society.
Getting “free” money on its own won’t encourage people to use less fossil energy and do less of the things currently driving climate change. UBI schemes also consider monetary income as the route to meeting basic needs, strengthening the role of money in everyday life and leaving existing social relations untouched. Such schemes might entice politicians to cut resources from public services.