UBI will skyrocket taxes that get externalized onto the poor
Lustig, professor of economics at Tulane University and Pabon postdoc fellow in developmental economics at Yale 2022
[Nora and Valentina Martinez, postdoc fellow in developmental economics at Yale, “Universal Basic Income, Taxes, and the Poor”, LSE Public Policy Review, November 24, https://ppr.lse.ac.uk/articles/10.31389/lseppr.67 [7-11-23|GDI|SPB]]
Implementing a budget-neutral UBI that does not hurt the poor could be quite challenging. With pre-UBI levels of spending on transfers and subsidies, when present, fiscal impoverishment is likely to persist. In the best of cases the poverty reducing effect will be smaller than under the current programs. The negative effects on poor people’s postfiscal income from switching to a UBI could be tempered if the funds available for such a change go beyond current spending on cash transfers and price subsidies. If the goal for the policy change to be budget neutral was maintained, however, this increase in spending would need to be matched by increased taxes or reductions in spending on other categories. Our results suggest that if budget neutrality is to be achieved by raising direct or indirect taxes paid by households, the implied increase in tax burdens for top deciles would be significant, even if the progressivity of tax rates remains unchanged. Efficiency costs and political resistance could make such a policy change a nonstarter in most low- and middle-income countries. Of course, the pressure on tax burdens could be eased by lowering the generosity of the UBI transfer. However, this would hurt the poor. Such a trade-off needs to be carefully assessed before introducing a UBI reform.