Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Without a massive boost in affordable housing supply, UBI can’t solve

Clarke, lecturer in sociology at the University of New South Wales, 2022

[Andrew, “Can a basic income help address homelessness? A Titmussian Perspective”, Journal of Sociology, November 15, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/14407833221135986 7-13-2023 GDI-SPB]

Hence, for a BI to be effective in addressing homelessness, it must be implemented as part of a ‘BI-services-regulation hybrid’ (Malleson & Calnitsky, 2021). Central to the ‘services’ component of this hybrid would be an expanded social housing sector to boost the supply of affordable housing and reduce competition for low-cost private rentals. Social housing provides far greater levels of housing stability and affordability than the private rental market and has been shown to prevent homelessness for disadvantaged households (O’Donnell, 2021). However, the increasingly residualised nature of the social housing sector in liberal/liberalising welfare states means that these benefits are only available to an increasingly narrow group of high-needs households (Clarke et al, 2022). In Australia, this situation means that many people experiencing or at risk of homelessness are either unable to access social housing or must wait for extended periods – sometimes years – to do so (Clarke et al, 2022; Clarke & Parsell, 2020). Expanding the supply and loosening the targeting of social housing is thus essential to addressing homelessness – and the closer it can become to a universal (i.e. untargeted) service, the greater the impact it will have. Importantly, pairing a BI with existing forms of targeted housing assistance, such as rental subsidies and housing vouchers, is unlikely to achieve the same gains as pairing it with social housing. Subsidies and vouchers tend to be deployed in lieu of efforts to address the cost and supply of affordable housing, and thus suffer similar problems to a stand-alone BI. That is, they presume the efficacy of the market in meeting the needs of at-risk groups, meaning their capacity to address homelessness is contingent on market conditions. Anderson-Baron and Collins (2019) showed that the use of housing vouchers by Canadian housing first programs was rendered ineffective when housing markets tightened and costs rose above what vouchers could effectively mitigate. Similarly, Australian research shows that rental subsidies for low-income households, paid under the Commonwealth Rental Assistance scheme, did little to improve housing affordability in a context of rising rents, as illustrated by the fact that 46% of households that receive the subsidy are still in housing stress (Anglicare Australia, 2022). Pairing a BI with an expanded social housing sector would have several advantages vis-à-vis the task of addressing homelessness. On the one hand, access to social housing would limit the extent to which BI recipients are exposed to the vicissitudes of the private market. On the other hand, a BI would help ensure that social housing providers (non-profit organisations, state or local governments) have a stable rental revenue base – a constant problem where rents are set as a proportion of incomes (Jacobs, 2019) – as tenants would have a higher and more secure minimum income. It would also help alleviate the ongoing poverty experienced by many formerly homeless households that enter social housing, many of which rely on charity to supplement their meagre incomes (Parsell et al, 2021). Universal BI payments would mean this group had sufficient income to cover basic non-housing necessities (e.g. food, energy bills) and limit their reliance on charity, which many experience as shameful and degrading (Parsell et al, 2021). 12 Journal of Sociology 0(0) The hybrid could also usefully include regulatory measures to control that rate of rental increases. Rent control is a much maligned, but also much misunderstood, policy proposal, particularly in liberal welfare states where intervention in the market is erroneously seen as reducing housing quality and supply (Slater, 2021). However, they remain a commonly used housing policy tool across Europe and elsewhere (Kettunen & Ruonavaara, 2021); and most contemporary policies and proposals take account of the impact on landlords’ capacity to provide and maintain rental properties (Slater, 2021). While this is not the place to expound the varieties and nuances of rent control policy, it is worth noting that that well-designed rent controls could help guarantee the effectiveness of a BI in preventing homelessness. They would do this by ensuring that improvements in income levels brought about by a BI are not undone by runaway rental cost inflation. This will be especially important in contexts where access to social housing remains limited, or where its expansion is slow, and the bulk of lowincome households remain reliant on the private rental sector.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.