UBI leads to defunding of other social services – inevitable in a capitalist economy
Kerman, project scientist at Campbell family mental health institute, 2021
[Nick, “The Role of Universal Basic Income in Preventing and Ending Homelessness”, International Journal on Homelessness, September 28, https://ojs.lib.uwo.ca/index.php/ijoh/article/view/13337 7-13-2023 GDI-SPB]
A transformative change in policy that affects numerous sectors and services, such as UBI, inevitably carries risks. The most serious concern is the extent to which other services that comprise social safety nets, which are complementary but not duplicative of UBI, are defunded. Implementation of UBI would replace some existing services, such as income support programs, but there is risk that other publicly funded health and social services would also be defunded. As noted by Raphael et al. (2019), it is important to recognize the neoliberal context in which a UBI would be implemented and how this could lead to such a policy being shaped to meet corporate interests and used to cut social services. This risk will be inherently present should UBI be designed and implemented in capitalistic economies, raising the need for caution, though there are considerations for risk mitigation. UBI must not be framed as a poverty reduction panacea, nor it is one for preventing and ending homelessness. Although UBI has the potential to reduce homelessness rates, it will not produce needed changes on other, ongoing crises that afflict large proportions of this population, such as the overdose crisis, inequitable access to mental health services, or the lack of investments to build new affordable housing. As such, advocacy on homelessness neither starts nor ends with UBI and the goal must be to develop a menu of systems- and individual-level interventions to address homelessness, one of which may be a guaranteed annual income. Another risk mitigation strategy would be to test the cost-effectiveness of UBI in controlled experiments. Being able to make a compelling moral and economic case for UBI as a strategy for addressing homelessness may create fiscal space to protect other health and social services against austerity measures. Nevertheless, the erosion of other components of the social safety net following UBI implementation remains an uncertain risk to efforts to prevent and end homelessness.