Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

UBI creates negative work incentive and disempowers workers

Afscharian, et al, Institute of Political Science - Germany, 2022

[Dominic Afscharian, “The State of the UBI Debate: Mapping the Arguments for and against UBI”, Basic Income Studies June 17, 2022, access info https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/bis-2021-0030/html accessed 7-11-23 (KG)]

Opponents of UBI strongly disagree with these points. One of the most popular arguments against UBI concerns this specific category of arguments: allegedly, UBI or some of its elements by themselves would create a negative work incentive (Bick et al., 2018; Caillé, 1994; Fourier, 1836; Gorz, 1985, 1999; Hamilton & Martin- West, 2019, p. 322; Jones & Marinescu, 2018; Laín, 2019; McLuhan, 1966; Midões, 2019; Mill, 1849; Rhys-Williams, 1943; Zelleke, 2008, p. 5), thus not only failing to solve (Jones & Marinescu, 2018; Krämer, 2019), but even worsening unemployment, resulting in a society in which nobody would continue to do hard but essential jobs (Heaven, 2019). As UBI cannot replace the dignity and fulfillment provided by work (Coote & Yazici, 2019, p. 24), this would have particularly harmful effects. Furthermore, UBI-sceptics are concerned that working conditions would either be unaffected (Birnbaum & De Wispelaere, 2021, p. 916) or even deteriorate: as employers know that workers can sustain a living anyway, they might pay lower wages (Coote & Yazici, 2019, p. 24; Standing, 2017, p. 51) and increase the number of part-time jobs (Gaskell, 2018). On the other hand, should wages actually rise, this would increase costs for producers (Tcherneva, 2005, p. 9), potentially driving companies out of business. Finally, more economically left-wing actors argue that UBI would distract from and reproduce the systemic problems associated with capitalism (Bayon, 2021; Lombardozzi & Pitts, 2020; Mathers, 2020, p. 333) and from organising workers (Gourevitch & Stanczyk, 2018), thus preventing actually meaningful liberation of workers. Authors like Howard and Wright object to this and consider UBI and socialism compatible (Howard, 2005; Wright, 2005).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.